The pie may not look like much especially when you just get a peice but it's the best out I've ever had. I've ordered a whole pie as well and was amazing. The soft serve also got here perfectly chilled even on the hottest of days. The peanut butter has a salty but realistic taste to it and the birthday cake is not to sweet. They never disappoint.
N
Nychole W
Experto local • 27 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 15/12/24
• DoorDash order
Not sure if my expectations were too high or what but it was very underwhelming. The best item I had was the Milk Bar Pie Slice! Would get that again. I also got the 3 Cookie Deal and the corn cookie was terrible, i threw it away. The cornflake cookie and compost were good but I hated that they were prepackaged and not warmed at the very least? It seems kinda lazy but decent nonetheless. The Cereal Milk Soft Serve Cup was what I was most excited to try and it was the most underwhelming. It just tasted like regular vanilla ice cream. I honestly wouldnt waste your time going here. Try one of the other many local bakeries! Maybe it wouldve been better if I had it before the fame like other reviewers mention.
K
Kirstyn B
1 contribuciones
Liked
• 8/7/25
• DoorDash order
The pie Milk Bar Pie Slice was good, the Marshmallow Brownie Gooey Bar super chocolatey. We ordered 3 but only sent 1. Gluten Free Birthday Cake Slice was really good for being gluten free and one of the best ones we'd had in a while.
K
Kevin L
4 contribuciones
Loved
• 26/2/24
• DoorDash order
The 15th Anniversary Cake Slice & The Red Velvet Cheesecake Cake Slice are both off the hook! Very tasty and Very rich! Depending on your sweet tooth there's enough for two in each slice!
S
SOPHIA G
Nuevo experto • 23 contribuciones
Loved
• 18/10/22
• DoorDash order
Insanely moist and fresh, it's insane how much better this location is than the others downtown... the Birthday Cake Slice from the flagship store is a whole different thing! And it's soooo good!
