This was our first time trying Mr.Pickles and we were blown out of the water! Not only were the sandwiches DELICIOUS, they were huge, fresh, and filling. We're already excited for our leftovers tomorrow! The Meatball Whole was hot, extremely flavorful and filling. The Big Jake Whole was stuffed, and one of the best sandwiches I've ever had! The extra Sauces & Dressings were nicely packed and all there. They even gave us, two free, Hot Chocolate Chip Cookies which not only was extremely thoughtful, but much needed. They were so good! The perfect way to end our meal. Board and Brew has lost our business, Mr.Pickles from here on out! Thank you!
O
OC G
5 contribuciones
Loved
• 15/6/26
• DoorDash order
How do I say I'm a connoisseur without saying I'm a connoisseur of roast beef? It was so rare that it melted in my mouth. The flavor profile was complex and delightful. Best sandwich I have had in years. I've never been mad about not taking pic of my food until today. 5 out of five stars. 100% recommend.
Jessica B
Experto local • 31 contribuciones
Loved
• 18/4/26
• DoorDash order
I enjoyed the Cali Tuna - it was a great portion, veggies and tuna were fresh, and I would definitely get it again. I can't wait to have it with the garlic sauce and onions - but I didn't get those because I didn't want to have stinky breath all day 🤣. I also got Large Fountain & Chips only because they didn't have Starry (aka Sierra Mist) in a bottle. Definitely worth the combo, especially with a BOGO deal.
-
-ian- .
Nuevo experto • 6 contribuciones
Loved
• 26/1/26
• DoorDash review
[Summary]
Mr. Pickle is one of those in the rotation i'm always happy to see. In the many times i've had it DoorDashed / Catered, it's always very tasty.
[Food]
Pretty much stick to the Goomba, Italian, or BLAT, as i don't eat bird. Choice of bread is always nice if wanting to mix it up a little. Consistent quailty.
The garlic sauce is dangerously delicious! If you're like me definitely wear a napkin bib, as I go pretty hard in the amount dripped into the sandwich, and try as I might to contain it, gravity will do its damndest to complete the sauce ➜ clothes circuit, resulting in a furious rapid cleanup to stop the oil.
And don't even get me started on the cookies! That fresh-baked goodness is irresistible, and will ultimately make any day Mr. Pickle arrives be a cheat day, no matter how strong the will not to is.
[TL;DR Verdict]
Food:
• Sandwich flirting with S-Tier for portion sizes and good mix of flavor, just on their own merit. Add the garlic sauce and you're now there.
• DoorDash-ability: A-B-Tier. All Items are labled, but some days are just the coded order with mods listed and not name of orderer.
• As a Catering Option: S-Tier, as the labels are there and they don't skimp on the garlic sauce that comes with the box.
M
Marianne C
Nuevo experto • 13 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 23/5/25
• DoorDash review
Sorry guys/gals. Been ordering from you for YEARS. Quality always good never doubted it. However, this evening was a disappointment. Ordered a beef dip on crunch roll..as always.. the crunch roll was a bit smaller on a overly crunchy roll. Beef brown, dry NO flavor, cheese almost non existent. What happened?! I have always recommended you to family and friends. This beef dip was a major miss step. One good thing, your potato salad is still yummy albeit the serving’s smaller. . Spent over $21+ way too much for what was sent. Sorry, I am so let down.
