Fantastic place. I deliver for all of the big food delivery Co's.
That's important because I see & smell & deliver pizza from 90% of the pizza places.
For a truly amazing version of a New York Medium Pizza order from these folks. Period.
In the picture I pulled apart a slice to show the 'goo', but hear this. The best highest quality best pizza mozzarella is not white and stringy, it's a warm yellow cheese with more texture *and* flavor.
Their dough itself is not NY style, it's New Haven thicker more of a bread feel, but they soft bake so the texture of the pie is soft and stretchy and not a blackened blistered crunchy pie. Just my opinion after 67 yrs on the planet New Haven style is great, I just personally never liked it.
Their pizza sauce is naturally sweet, I've been a line chef & I know when a sauce's sweetness is from the highest quality tomatoes, and not from added sweeteners (yes many do that).
The cheese I already said I love, and the sprinkling of oil is the last ingredient in a top-flight New York pizza.
I choose to add basil & fredh tomatoes for a couple of bucks.
The value of this very large 'medium' pie is extreme. Best price in the whole town and the best New York pizza anywhere within the entire area. 10/10
R
Ross E
Experto local • 25 contribuciones
Loved
• 17/9/25
• DoorDash order
The Small Calzone I ordered arrived with healthy sized portion of marinara sauce. Both the calzone and marinara were hot, fresh and delicious. It was flatter than most I've had in the past but still good.
T
Thomas V
Experto local • 40 contribuciones
Loved
• 3/5/24
• DoorDash order
Their medium puzza is an incredible value, a true classic New York style pizza. I added fresh tomato & basil, but it's great with just cheese. A pizza has to be able to stand on its own. If it does, then toppings make it even better. I think people sometimes add things like pepperoni because the pizza needs 'help' in the flavor dept. The pizza from Old Colony reminds me of the Long Island pizza I'd eaten for 47 yrs (no typo lol). The dough is decidedly New Haven style, but it just gives a bit of crunch to the edges, it doesn't change the pie.
The sauce here is less acidic than New Haven style. This sauce is sweet & mild, which is important for a New York pizza. A benefit of this is no acid problems for your tummy. It's a Super-good pie.
L
Lauren M
Experto local • 45 contribuciones
Loved
• 22/9/25
• DoorDash order
Classic Cheeseburger was delicious! Perfect mix of the greasiness of the burger and the crunch of the veggies. Fries transported well,too! Still crispy and flavorful. Large Pizza was delicious, as ususual.
S
Santiago C
Nuevo experto • 21 contribuciones
Loved
• 2/8/22
• DoorDash order
I constantly order from old colony pizza, and have just ordered the Hawaiian and fried dough. Both items were delicious and perfect, just like every order I get from this place is always cooked to perfection and extremely friendly people. The fried dough really surprised me with its size, being only $5!
