We wish to thank you for your continuous support and for adjusting with us again in response to the quickly changing needs of our day! Dine-In does not currently need face coverings. Our No-Contact Ra…
I order again and again from this restaurant and am rarely disappointed. The Tortellini with Portabella & Peas is delicious! Love that it comes with bread, butter, and a side too (personal enjoy the salad). Chocolate Cadillac Cake & Cannoli Cheesecake are to DIE for. Just incredible. Will absolutely order again.
A
Alex V
Nuevo experto • 22 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 11/10/22
• DoorDash order
The Buffalo beef and wing combo was very disappointing. $20 for 5 wings which were good, and the smallest beef on weck I've ever seen! Imagine a junior cheeseburger from Wendy's or Burger King. It was about that size with very little meat and very soggy. Do not order this if you're looking for a good beef on weck. Other things from Paynes are very good, so stick to Italian food from here :)
S
Samantha O
10 contribuciones
Loved
• 23/9/24
• DoorDash order
I already love this restaurant but decided to try out some new things and I really loved them!! The Smokin' Turkey & Bacon Sandwich is full and delicious and the French Onion Au Gratin was still steaming hot on arrival and equally tasty.
A
Alfonso D
Nuevo experto • 27 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 24/5/23
• DoorDash order
soup was spilled all over bag. Beer Battered Cheese Curds were burnt with all the cheese cooked out of them, barely any fries and the gravy was different and clumpy. normally love the food here but this order was way off
E
Emily D
Experto local • 50 contribuciones
Loved
• 21/5/26
• DoorDash order
Small Steak & Cheese Pizza genuinely never disappoints! A little on the spicy side this time but nothing too bad. Tortellini with Portabella & Peas is one of my favorite pastas to order anywhere! Would absolutely recommend trying either! The Cannoli Cheesecake was absolutely out of this world too. Overall, pricey order but so worth the quality and taste.
