Thou Shalt Eat Proper Pizza Welcome to Proper Pizza and Pasta! We offer a variety of ways to dine with us, whether you are looking for delivery, dine-in, or just trying to grab a quick slice to go. Co…
20" in 20" Cheese Pizza was superb and checked all the pizza boxes as a true to form NY style pie:
•large but THIN slices
• foldable, chewy sourdough like crust with rigid crispy bottom
• cheese blend on point, sauce homemade and authentic
•perfect sauce:cheese ratio
I live about 5-6 miles away so I know it was made to order, fresh, and not ice cold by the time it arrived! Bravo!
E
Elisha L
Nuevo experto • 12 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 10/7/25
• DoorDash order
Penne Vodkai ordered the pasta and added broccoli and mushrooms, 3 small pieces of broccoli, and basically no mushrooms for an upcharge. It is pretty ridiculous. The pizza is decent. However, I was in the mood for pasta, and this was for sure a letdown, probably wouldn't order this again.
J
Jeremy B
Experto local • 53 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 17/11/25
• DoorDash order
I tried the Penne Vodka and the Fettucine Alfredo. Items came super hot and fresh and this store was 5 miles away. The vodka saauce was very bland compared to others I've had. Alfredo sauce was fine. I'm glad I bought them at their sale price but I wouldn't order from here again. Portions are bigger elsewhere on DoorDash.
C
Carlos A
2 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 29/4/24
• DoorDash order
Received a fried calzone with hardly any cheese & didnt taste very good & a piece of lasagne that measured about four fingers wide & three fingers high, very small portion & didnt taste good either, I could have made my own lasagne for what I paid here for a tiny slice. The best part of the meal was the cookie I ordered which was delicious, the mini canoli was nothing special. Overall I think it's overpriced & overrated, nothing to write home about & return.
J
Jessica J
1 contribuciones
Didn't like
• 28/4/26
• DoorDash order
Half of the 16" Brooklyn Square Pizza was completely burned and tasted horrible and the other half undercooked andtreating like dough, making a $35 pizza inedible($40 if you include thepepperoni we added). The XL Hot Honey Pizza was cooked well and the Garlic Knots were delicious
