Oh my Gods, I have now found my local favorite New York style pizza place. The crust is thin enough that it can fold without being soggy, and the herbed crust has great flavor. The cheese blend has lots of flavor to it, and tastes like more than the standard mozzarella and parmesan blend. The pepperoni's perfect for the style they make, and the kitchen honored my request for a little well done. Staff should prepare to see my name once a month.
T
Tiffiany M
27 contributions
27/04/25
• DoorDash order
I am so very sad to say I won't be from ordering from this place again. They went from frankly amazing NY style pizza to cardboard crust pizza at some point since I last ordered. The herb crust now had almost no herbs with mediocre sauce. I don't know what changed or if this is them trying to keep prices stable, but the Cheese Pizza (Large 14") is now awful.
J
John J
2 contributions
27/01/25
• DoorDash order
Sandrine did a wonderful job getting our dinner to us. Smack Daddy makes some good Super Shroom Pizza (X-Large 16")
A
Angela N
2 contributions
24/10/24
• DoorDash order
Best pizza in Longmont, in my opinion. The Garlic knots are so rich and garlicky and buttery, they're a total treat.
C
Chantay E
5 contributions
08/06/24
• DoorDash review
The pizza is very good...fresh ingredients and wonderful crust. This is our favorite pizza spot, so glad we found you!
