We've returned to Barnegat with a classic menu of Italian delicacies, exquisite steaks, fresh seafood, and AMAZING thin crust brick oven pizza, based on our 20+ years of experience.
Matthew has succes…
Absolutely hands down the best food in the area.
The 2nd time now we have ordered the sliced steak sandwich and it's incredible. So much flavor.
Now add in the first time we tried their Scarpiello Wings & they are on par or better than any as have had from all over! TOP NOTCH!
First time we have had the tomato & garlic pie. (We have had other pies in the past) and when I tell you the flavor is second to none I'm not exaggerating. The coal oven crunch with tbe fresh tomato and garlic - HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
Don't hesitate- order now! You won't be disappointed!
C
Carl A
Emerging Expert • 64 contributions
11/8/24
• DoorDash order
Affumicato Burger and Roasted Garlic and Onion Soup were delicious. Surprise, surprise. They arrived hot and ready to eat without having to be reheated. Very rare for a door dash order. East Bay Italian Grille is the only place I can order from and actually get a hot meal delivered.
N
Nancy R
5 contributions
10/14/23
• DoorDash order
OHMYGAWD! You have to order from here!!! The wings with herbs are to die for for! The eggplant roasted peppers & mutt (3rd time I got this!) is perfect. I ordered too much food & froze this sandwich & put in oven to warm & WOW!!! Steak fries I always heat up in oven but I can't not have them! First time ordering the garlic onion soup, creamiest melted cheese! Awesome!
Haven't gotten to the filet steak tips with mushrooms & fried onions yet but that looks amazing also! Do NOT hesitate to order from here! You'll never cook again!
H
Heather D
Emerging Expert • 10 contributions
10/8/24
• DoorDash order
Both the rigatoni bolognese and rigatoni w/ sausage & broccoli rabe were delicious but the burger was a hockey puck. I asked for medium & it had no seasoning either. Seemed like it was an over cooked Costco burger. Probably not the best idea to order a burger from an Italian place but I figured everything else we've had has been good so why not? Won't do it again. The steak fries it came with were also super soggy.
J
Jimmy M
Emerging Expert • 65 contributions
11/26/23
• DoorDash order
6 Pieces Garlic Knots all dough not even cooked should have never been served. Chicken parmigiana worse than last time and last time was just average. Will not order again from this place.
