Honestly this is the best pizza I've ever had! We got the Original Margherita the crust is perfectly cooked and the flavor is perfection! The sauce to cheese ratio.... sensational! I mean they understood the assignment!!! We will definitely be back!
J
Jill M
2 contributions
7/4/25
• DoorDash review
Issue description...
Very cold pizza, possibly causing it to taste old, like it was made hours ago. Very disappointing considering how much I was looking forward to trying the pizza because of the reviews. I keep trying to find an authentic Neopolitan pizza and haven't had much luck. I was very excited to try, but delivery was disappointing, only because of the quality. This was the first time I used Door Dash. I don't blame them. My delivery girl was very nice and I tipped in cash, which everyone should do. Not sure if it was bad luck or because I had to order delivery instead of trying in person. To be specific, I ordered the margherita pizza and I also tried the tiramisu. The tiramisu tasted great, but the portion size was so small considering the price, especially compared to competitors. It's debatable if I chance it again. I don't mind spending money on great food, but when my first impression leaves me writing a not so positive review, I'm not so sure.
J
Jill M
2 contributions
7/5/25
• DoorDash order
This restaurant has now become my most favorite pizza place. The Original Margherita and the Tiramisu are absolutely amazing!!! The best I've had! Not only is the food incredible, so is the hospitality. I have not had the pleasure of dining there yet, but their customer service is on point. It was my first time ordering through Door Dash, as well as Original Flavor 1889. Unfortunately, Door Dash was disappointing the two times I ordered through them. Both times the pizza was delivered very cold. On the second time I ordered, the restaurant went above and beyond and called to let me know once the delivery person left their establishment to deliver my order because I had such a bad experience with the first order. I couldn't believe how much they went out of their way to ensure I knew how fresh my order was. Unfortunately, Door Dash was a disappointment. I'm not sure if I will use their services in the future. Original Flavor 1889 5 stars! Can't wait to dine there in person!
F
Faraz P
Local Expert • 39 contributions
3/24/24
• DoorDash order
Fantastic Pizza...dough is the best in Tampa Bay. Superior ingredients that speak to you. My fav in DTSP.
L
Lisa Z
13 contributions
2/19/24
• DoorDash order
The pizza was delicious. Thin, delicate crust. The tiramisu was good but it's a very small for the price. It's not square. It's a pie slice. They got more than 8 slices from this pie.
