This restaurant you are trying to reach is not available on DoorDash right now.Ok
4.6(1k+ ratings)•
DashPass•
Italian
•
Store Info
DashPass
4.6(1k+ ratings)•
$$•Italian
Mercer Pennsylvania’s newest, fast casual create your own pizza shop. Third Eye Pies serves a variety of fast fired, hand crafted pizzas. Go beyond the pies, try one of our fresh salad bowls.
Club med pizza was delicious. Crust was nice and crispy. Salad was fresh and a good size.
A
Amy M
4 contributions
1/27/23
• DoorDash review
It takes a lot to impress me when it comes to pizza. This place is pretty good. If you are a toppings person then look no further than Third Eye Pies.
Unfortunately I am not a toppings person due to food allergies, so I had to settle for the two plainest cheese only pies. Nevertheless they weren't bad. I'd say they'd be a great option for a picky person or a child as they were simple, not too spicy, but not too bland. I didn't care for the crust, that's my only complaint and reason I couldn't give a perfect review. The crust was too chewy and ashy. If you have a loaded pizza you won't notice it. But I unfortunately didn't have toppings to mask the less than stellar crust. Next time I will try the cauliflower crust. If it's good then I'll submit a 5 star review.
My husband ordered the chicken parmesan pizza and the Nashville hot chicken pizza. He raved about both, said they were equally perfect with sauce to cheese to toppings ratios, and said it was the best pizza he's ever had. As a former chicken eater and above average home cook (before my food allergies made my life difficult) I know what quality chicken dishes look like. Third Eye Pies absolutely nailed what both chicken parmesan and Nashville hot chicken should taste like in pizza form.
Finally, this place takes dessert pizza to the next level. We ordered the s'mores pizza, and I couldn't believe it was a pizza and not a pricy dessert at some high class restaurant in NYC. Well done. I want to try the peach dessert pizza next time.
I hope this place continues to maintain such high quality, diversity of choice, and value. If so I believe it's here for the long haul.
T
Trish B
1 contributions
11/8/23
• DoorDash order
$45 for very little food the Creme Brulee Cheesecake was good the Peanut Butter Landslide was good but a very thin piece
the pizza very very thin crust was hard to eat the crust was more like a cracker the flavor was ok
The Half Dozen Garlic Breadsticks were good
T
Tatiana H
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
5/28/23
• DoorDash order
Im a trucker so I eat pizza all over the country. Everything was absolutely perfect.The best pizza hands down. I dont even like crust and even the crust was delicious.
E
Ella L
1 contributions
1/24/23
• DoorDash review
I had a cheese pizza and a side of cheesy bread. The food was amazing. Not too much crust, the toppings were delicious and all worked together great and the cheesy bread is the best ive had. I high recommend this place for your pizzas!!
