Fenicci's of Hershey is a restaurant with a long history in the town of Hershey, as our residents know.
The restaurant has been open for wonderful meals and enjoyable moments with family and friends s…
The only thing missing was the little chocolate shavings that probably would've melted maybe on the way here so they could've melted on the way here, but there was one little chocolate, half moon shaving on top of the dark side of the moon. The food is absolutely 100% fabulous for takeout and we've ate there one time while staying overnight in a hotel but since we have family here now we are housesitting and this was the first place that came to mind for good real Italian! The tortellini marinara is something I try to make it home. I thought I made it up lol! Ha - no of course leave the genius to the real Italian restaurants! 5 star service , 5 star food, and 5 stars for the Tirzeptide shot I decided to skip yesterday so I can pig out on my favorite!!
J
Joe R
239 contributions
Liked
• 1/18/24
• DoorDash order
The Arancini Balls were crispy on the outside, and deliciously soft on the inside. The Chicken Marsala had plenty of mushrooms, the fettuccine was not overcooked, and the marsala wine sauce was tasty. My only criticism is that the chicken breast was a tad overcooked. Overall a really great Italian meal. I'm looking forward to the key lime pie!
D
Dwayne H
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 3/20/26
• DoorDash order
I normally do not give bad reviews but this place was horrible. The Chicken Marsala was a dry piece of chicken breast with mushrooms on it. No sauce or flavor. The noodles smelt and tasted like they were boiled in water that previously had seafood cooked in it. I hope this was an off night but just beware. I also forgot to mention the wedge salad was a half head of lettuce with an extensive amount of onions, a big chunk of blue cheese and dressing everywhere. Looked very thrown together.
J
Jason E
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/5/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered veal saltimbocca as an entree to be delivered. The taste was good, but for an entree and the little box showed up with one piece of veal in it and 10 cents worth of pasta.
Better off going to Sapranos in Campbelltown and get real veal saltimbocca with prosciutto and mushrooms.
Feniccis version is an appetizer and for 37.00 I got an appetizer delivered.
I don't think they have to pay tariffs on veal !
L
Lyz S
Emerging Expert • 6 contributions
Liked
• 8/21/23
• DoorDash order
The Chicken Picatta was really good but the chicken was very dry. I ordered a Wedge and unexpectedly it came with no dressing on it, so $11 for literally just a wedge of a head of lettuce was not worth it. The Tiramisu was amazing though, not traditional but delicious!
