Buttercooky Bakery & Café Menu

$$Cupcakes, Pastries, Bakery, Cookies

Get delivery or pickup from Buttercooky Bakery & Café when you order online with DoorDash

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Menu

Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest store

Coffee Station proudly serving La Colombe Roasters

Large Coffee

$4 +

Large Iced Cappucino

$6.5 +

Large Iced Coffee

$5.95 +

Double Espresso

$4.5 +

Espresso

$4 +

Small Mocha

$6.25 +

Large Mocha

$6.95 +

Large Iced Tea

$5 +

Cortado

$5 +

Pumpkin Draft Latte Large

$7.75 +

Croissants

Chocolate Croissant

$6.95 +

Raspberry Cheese Croissant

$6.95 +

Almond Croissant

$6.95 +

Strawberry Almond Twice Baked Croissant

$6.95 +

Nutella Croissant

$6.95 +

Bear Claw Croissant

Chocolate & Toasted Coconut Croissant

$6.95 +

Omelets

Make it Your Own

Traditional three egg omelette served with toast & home fries.

$16 +

Meat Lover's Omelet

Four eggs folded. sausage, bacon, ham, cheddar, roasted potatoes, bread

$18.95 +

Greek Omelet

four eggs folded, cherry tomatoes, red onions, calamata olives, feta, roasted potatoes, toasted italian bread

$18.95 +

World Cup USA Dessert

USA Cupcake

$7 +

World Cup Cookie

$8.95 +

Assorted Danish

Pecan Danish

$6 +

Cinnamon Danish

$6 +

Blueberry Danish

$6 +

Pineapple Danish

$6 +

Cherry Danish

$6 +

Almond Danish

$6 +

Raspberry Danish

$6 +

Mochaccino Danish

Chocolate Babka & Espresso based danish/bun

$6 +

1 Dozen Assorted Danish

$58 +

Specialty Drink/Smoothies/Shakes

M&M Shake

Chocolate ice cream and milk, topped with whipped cream, M&M candies & chocolate sauce.

$12.95 +

Oreo Mountain

Vanilla ice cream, milk and Oreo cookies topped with whipped cream, Oreo crumbs, white & dark chocolate sauces.

$12.95 +

The Buttercooky

Vanilla or chocolate ice cream with milk, topped with whipped cream, cake crumbs & rainbow sprinkles.

$12.95 +

Chocolate Chunk

Chocolate chips, whipped cream & chocolate sauce.

$10.25 +

The Classic Frappe

Vanilla, Caramel, or Chocolate Sauce

$10.25 +

Hot Chocolate

$6 +

Nutella Hot Chocolate

$6.5 +

Berry Balance

Blackberries, blueberries, strawberries & raspberries.

$13.5 +

Acai Smoothie

Acai, strawberry, banana, acai juice.

$13.5 +

Banana Blues

Bananas, blueberries, low fat yogurt

$13.5 +

ALL DAY BREAKFAST

The Breakfast Sandwich

Two eggs any style served on a roll. Comes with American Cheese and Bacon

$9.75 +

EGG SANDWICH

NO BACON, NO CHEESE, ONLY EGGS ON ROLL

$5.95 +

EGG & CHEESE SANDWICH

EGG AND CHEESE ON A ROLL NO BACON

$6.95 +

Breakfast Burrito

three eggs scrambled, cheddar, spinach, pico de gallo, avocado, roasted potato, pickled shallot, sriracha, grilled wrap

$19.95 +

Breakfast Bun

two eggs scrambled, bacon, avocado, caramelized onion, arugula, herbed lemon aioli

$14.95 +

Miso Mushroom Egg Toast

Miso sautéed portobello mushrooms, herbed scrambled eggs, goat cheese, arugula, garlic confit, toasted country loaf

$23.95 +

Avocado Toast with Single Egg

$22.95 +

The Breakfast Crepe

Two eggs any style with bacon and choice of cheese.

$16.95 +

The Classic Crepe

Chocolate sauce & fresh strawberries or raspberries.

$15.95 +

Crumb Cake Slice

$4.95 +

Crumb Bun Slice

$4.95 +

Cold Beverages

Orange Juice

$3 +

Apple Juice

$3 +

Diet Coke

$3 +

Coco-Cola

$3 +

Pellegrino

$3 +

Figi Water

$3 +

Poland Spring

$2 +

Cranberry Juice

$3 +

Grape Juice

$3 +

Sparkling Ice Black Raspberry

$3.5 +

Donuts

Jelly Donut

$4.95 +

Vanilla Frosted Donut

$4.95 +

Chocolate Frosted Donut

$4.95 +

Vanilla French Cruller Donut

$4.95 +

Chocolate French Cruller Donut

$4.95 +

Vanilla Boston Cream Donut

$4.95 +

Chocolate Boston Cream Donut

$4.95 +

Vanilla Donut with Sprinkles

$4.95 +

One Dozen Assorted Donuts

$55 +

Breakfast Pastries

Apple Strudel

$16.95 +

Peach Boat Puff Pastry

$6 +

1lb Assorted Rugelach

Apricot, Chocolate and Raspberry

$18.95 +

Chocolate Cigar

(Puff Pastry Dough)

$6 +

Palmier (Elephant Ear Cookie)

$6 +

Chocolate Dipped Almond Horn

$6 +

Sugar Free Pastry

Apple, Cherry, Blueberry

$6 +

Powdered Almond Horn

$6 +

Breakfast Rings

Fruit Ring

$16.95 +

Chocolate Horn Ring

$16.95 +

Large Crumb Cake

$18.95 +

Pecan Ring

$16.95 +

Apple Horn Ring

$16.95 +

Cheese Danish Ring

$16.95 +

Almond Paste Ring

$16.95 +

Blueberry Pudding Ring

$16.95 +

Muffins

Bran Muffin

$5.25 +

Corn Muffin

$5.25 +

Bluberry Muffin

$5.25 +

Lemon Poppy Muffin

$5.25 +

Chocolate Chip Muffin

$5.25 +

Gluten Free Muffin

$5.25 +

Carrot Muffin

$5.25 +

Apple Muffin

$5.25 +

All Chocolate Muffin

$5.25 +

1 Dozen Assorted Muffins

$55 +

Sandwiches & Wraps

Huntington Sandwich

Chicken Cutlet, Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Cole Slaw, Russian Dressing on a hot hero

$18.95 +

Chicken Gorgonzola Panini

Caramelized onion, gorgonzola, mayo & arugula.

$16.95 +

Vegetarian Panini

Roasted red peppers, portobello mushroom, grilled eggplant, spinach & basil pesto.

$16.95 +

Chicken Garlic

Grilled Herb Chicken, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella, charred garlic mayonnaise

$16.95 +

Caprese Panini

Tomato, fresh mozzarella, spinach & basil pesto.

$16.95 +

Turkey Apple

Mayo, granny smith apple, red onion & goat cheese.

$16.95 +

Chicken Quesadilla

$16.95 +

Chicken Cutlet Panini

Breaded chicken, lettuce, tomato, mozzarella

$16.95 +

Turkey B.L.A.T.

oven roasted turkey breast, bacon, lettuce, avocado, tomatoes, honey mustard on wrap

$16.95 +

Chicken Caesar

Chicken Caesar Wrap

$16.95 +

Quiche

Lorraine Quiche Served with Salad

Bacon, Cheese

$15.95 +

Traditional Quiche Served with Salad

Broccoli and Cheese

$15.95 +

Florentine Quiche Served with Salad

Sun Dried Tomato, Spinach & Sharp Cheese

$15.95 +

Whole Quiche

Traditional, Lorraine, Florentine

$34.95 +

Scones

Blueberry Scone

$5.25 +

Chocolate Chip Scone

$5.25 +

Cranberry Walnut Scone

$5.25 +

1 Dozen Assorted Scones

$55 +

Freshly Made Salads

Asian Caesar Salad

Romaine Lettuce, Napa cabbage, wontons, parmesan, ginger aioli dressing

$19.95 +

Quinoa Salad

Spinach, avocado, tri color peppers, cranberries & lemon vinaigrette.

$19.95 +

Grilled Chicken Avocado Salad

$21.95 +

Warm Grain Bowl

Mixed greens, 6-minute egg, red quinoa, avocado, grilled tomatoes, roasted red peppers, radish, sunflower seeds, feta, cilantro, lemon vinaigrette

$21.95 +

House Salad

Arugula, cranberries, caramelized walnuts, goat cheese, cherry tomatoes & raspberry vinaigrette.

$17.5 +

Brownies

Oreo Brownie

$6 +

Fudge Brownie

$6 +

Bread

Semolina

$5.5 +

Italian Bread

$4.5 +

Salt Stick

$2 +

Rye Bread Seedless

$6.5 +

Challah Bread

$6.5 +

Turnovers

Apple Turnover

$5.25 +

Cherry Turnover

$5.25 +

Blueberry Turnover

$5.25 +

Other Dishes & Sides

Chicken Fingers & Fries

Served with French fries.

$12.95 +

yogurt & Granola Bowl

Greek yogurt, homemade granola, berry jam, seasonal fruits, honey

$15.75 +

Soup Du Jour

Chicken Noodle, Clam Chowder, Broccoli Cheddar

$10.95 +

Sweet Potato Fries

$4 +

Home Fries

$4 +

Bacon

$4 +

Mixed fruit bowl

$9.95 +

French Fries

$5 +

grilled chicken

$7 +

Turkey Bacon

$5 +

Pastries/Eclairs

NY Cheesecake Pastry

$8.95 +

Chocolate Mousse Pastry

Rich and creamy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of moist chocolate cake topped with chocolate curls

$8.95 +

Banana Milk Chocolate Bar

Banana bread and banana mousse infused with salted caramel, encased in milk chocolate wafer crunch, topped with whipped ganache

$8.95 +

Pistachio Sunflower French Pastry

Pistachio mousse dipped in crunchy pistachio wafer chocolate set beneath a raspberry crémeux sphere, resting on soft vanilla cake & a buttery vanilla sablé cookie finished with a handcrafted white chocolate sunflower and a dollop of raspberry jam

$8.95 +

The Strawberry Pastry

Strawberry Filling atop a sable cookie.

$9.95 +

The Mango Pastry

White chocolate Shell containing soft Mango Filling, Mango cremeux and fresh mango

$9.95 +

Fresh Fruit Tart

Silky rich custard cream in a dark chocolate dipped buttery vanilla sablé tart topped with strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, blackberries, mandarin oranges and kiwi.

$9.95 +

By The Slice / Cannoli's

Cannoli

Our signature cannoli filling in a crispy fried shell

$6 +

Carrot Cake Slice

Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and lush cream cheese icing & a marzipan carrot

$6.95 +

Lobster Tail Pastry

Crispy flaky shell baked gorgeously golden filled with light and delicious bavarian cream

$6.95 +

Napolean Slice

Gorgeously golden crispy layers of puff pastry filled with rich custard pastry cream, finished with a glossy royal icing

$6.95 +

Tiramisu Slice

Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream & dusted with cocoa powder

$6.95 +

Chocolate Cannoli

Our signature cannoli filling in a chocolate covered crispy fried shell

$6 +

Philly Fluff (Cream Cheese Pound Cake)

Moist and fluffy pound cake made with cream cheese and cinnamon . Marble or plain.

$16.95 +

Cakes

Tres Leche

Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted 3-milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries

$41.95 +

Vanilla Chocolate Cake

Vanilla Cake Chocolate Filling Chocolate Icing

$31.95 +

Cannoli Cake

Layers of moist vanilla cake and our delicious cannoli cream with chocolate chips finished with a chocolate drip and pieces of cannolis

$33.95 +

Silk & Satin Mousse

Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous NY style cheesecake set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with a nest of chocolate ganache, gold dusted lines and lathered in roasted almond slices

$38.95 +

Passion Fruit Mango Mousse

Tropical sweet yet tangy passion fruit creme set atop thin moist vanilla cake lightly soaked in Malibu vanilla creme filled with Mango Mousse brulee syrup finished with a tie-dye tropical fruit glaze and garnished with fresh berries Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$38.95 +

Carrot Cake

Smooth and silky cream cheese sandwiched between deeply moist layers of carrot cake baked with golden raisins, finished with super soft and lush sweet cream cheese, a marzipan carrot and lathered in toasted coconut flakes

$31.95 +

Mini Birthday Cake Vanilla

Vanilla buttercream between layers of moist vanilla cake, finished with smooth vanilla buttercream, carefully handcrafted buttercream flowers, and vanilla cake crumbs

$14.95 +

Cheesecakes

Oreo Cheesecake

$26.95 +

Strawberry Cheesecake

$26.95 +

New York Cheesecake

$24.95 +

Pies & Fruit Tart

8" Lemon Meringue Pie

$29.95 +

Apple Pie

$26.95 +

Blueberry Pie

$26.95 +

Cherry Pie

$26.95 +

Apple Crumb Pie

$26.95 +

Brownie Tart

Brownie with Ganache icing in Tart Shell

$9.95 +

Small Apple Pie

$9.95 +

Small Blueberry Pie

$9.95 +

Small Cherry Pie

$9.95 +

Small Pecan Pie

$9.95 +

Large Cookies

Chocolate Chip Cookie

$6 +

Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie

$6 +

Reese's Peanut Butter Cookie

$6 +

Chinese Cookie

$6 +

Sugar Cookie

$6 +

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

$6 +

M & M Cookie

$6 +

Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie

$6 +

FAMOUS TRES LECHE CAKE

Tres Leche Cake

Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted three milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries and blueberries.

$41.95 +

Gluten Free Items

7" NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free)

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$28.15 +

7" Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$33.45 +

Gluten Free Brownie

$5 +

Gluten Free Cookie

Chocolate Chip or Sugar

$5 +

Individual NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free)

Smooth and silky cream cheese (gluten-free).

$6.25 +

Individual Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)

Smooth and silky cream cheese finished with fluffy whipped cream and a fresh strawberry (gluten-free).

$8.1 +

Creme Brulee

$6.95 +

1 Pound Pignoli Cookie

$38 +

Cupcakes & Cake Pops

Red Velvet Cupcake

$5.95 +

Oreo Cupcake

$5.95 +

Carrot Cupcake

$5.95 +

Chocolate Classic Cupcake

Chocolate With Sprinkles and Cherry on Top

$5.95 +

Vanilla Classic Cupcake

Soft vanilla cupcake topped with smooth white frosting, colorful sprinkles, and a cherry.

$5.95 +

Chocolate Cake pop

$3.95 +

Vanilla Cake Pop

$3.95 +

Custom Order ( Pre-ordered with our staff)

Custom Order

Please call the store first to place your order. Enter the invoice number in special instructions. (631) 424 -4034

$25 +

4th of July

4th of July Buttercream Cake

$34.95 +

Halloween Themed Dessert

Halloween Themed Cupcake

$5.95 +

Halloween Themed Cake Pop

$4.95 +

Halloween Decorated Cookie

$6.95 +

Witchy Pumpkin Cake

Feeds 8-10 People Funfetti Cake Vanilla Filling Decorated for Halloween

$38.95 +

Frankenstein Cake

Feeds 8-10 People Chocolate Cake Chocolate Fudge Filling Decorated for Halloween like Frankenstein

$38.95 +

Fall Favorites

Pumpkin Muffin

Spiced pumpkin muffin topped with a crumbly cinnamon streusel, capturing the essence of fall flavors.

$5.25 +

Apple Cider Donut

Coated in cinnamon sugar, this donut features the rich flavor of apple cider, offering a classic taste of fall.

$4.75 +

Carrot Muffin

$5.25 +

Pumpkin Draft Latte Small

$6.75 +

Pumpkin Draft Latte Large

Rich pumpkin-infused coffee with creamy milk, creating a smooth and aromatic blend.

$7.75 +

Fall Themed Cupcake

Decorated with intricate lattice frosting, this cupcake features rich, flavors.

$5.5 +

Fall Themed Cake Pop

$3.95 +

Pumpkin Croissant

$8.95 +

Fall Themed Funfetti Cake

$29.95 +

Hanukkah Dessert

Jelly Donut with Powdered Sugar

$4.95 +

Jelly Donut with Powdered Sugar

$4.95 +

Hanukkah Themed Cupcake

$5.95 +

Hanukkah Themed Cake Pop

$4.25 +

Menorah Cake

Menorah Themed Cake Chocolate Fudge Filling Chocolate Cake

$37.95 +

Hanukkah Themed Cookie

$7.95 +

Hanukkah Themed Cake

Vanilla Cake Vanilla Buttercream

$35.95 +

Hanukkah Themed Vanilla and Chocolate Cake

Vanilla Cake Van and Chocolate Buttercream

$35.95 +

St Joseph's/Irish Soda Bread

St. Patrick's Themed Merengue Cookie Bag

Colorful meringue cookies in green, orange, and white, adorned with festive sprinkles, celebrating St. Patrick's Day.

$14.95 +

Similar Businesses

Tim Hortons RaceTrac Kwik Trip Sprouts Farmers Market Crumbl Sonic Drive-In Denny's The Ice Cream Shop Dairy Queen Potbelly Sandwich Works Baskin-Robbins CVS Starbucks Red Robin Gourmet Burgers and Brews Domino's Pizza

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Menu