Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream Menu
American, Ice Cream Store
Get delivery or pickup from Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream when you order online with DoorDash
Lake Effect Artisan Ice Cream Menu
Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest storeCategories
- Pints
- Mystery Box
Pints
Frozen Hot Chocolate Pint
Get ready for something special. This isn’t just chocolate—it’s frozen hot chocolate, transformed into a rich, creamy ice cream experience.
$10 +
Silver Cloud Vanilla Pint
Silver Cloud Estates vanilla beans are responsibly grown exclusively in the beautiful Nilgiri Mountains of southern India. We use this vanilla to bring you this outstanding vanilla ice cream.
$10 +
Paula's Glazed Donut Pint
The union of two of Buffalo's favorite treats into a tag team of deliciousness. Our rich glaze donut flavored ice cream blended with big chunks of Paula's Donut glazed fry cake pieces. A masterpiece!
$10 +
Peanut Butter Epiphany Pint
When we decided to make a peanut butter ice cream, you had better believe that it is the best you’ll ever have! Rich and creamy peanut butter ice cream with chunks of chocolate and chopped peanuts throughout!
$10 +
Extra Cookies, Extra Cream Pint
Our take on the classic cookies and cream. We take our vanilla, add a swirl of white chocolate cream, and then add a ton of oreo chunks to create this elevated flavor!
$10 +
Salty Caramel Pint
Our award-winning, sweet and salty masterpiece! With just a pinch of pure sea salt, this decadent caramel ice cream is unlike anything you have ever experienced. Rich, unique, and absolutely unbelievable.
$10 +
Big Wayne's Cake Batter Pint
Just ask yourself... Are you one of those people who like to lick the bowl after making a cake? Boy... is this flavor for you! You’re going to love this creamy and supremely decadent yellow cake batter ice cream.
$10 +
Cookie Dough Pint
Chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough and mini chocolate chips folded into our creamy Silver Cloud Vanilla ice cream.
$10 +
House Chocolate Pint
We created a new cocoa blend just for this ice cream. A deep, rich milk chocolate not to be missed!
$10 +
Steamworks Coffee Pint
Teaming up with our friends at Steamworks Coffee, we use a custom blend of their beans—ground Turkish-style—to infuse a depth of flavor that goes far beyond your typical coffee ice cream.
$10 +
Mystery Box
To Go Mystery Box
-2 pints of ice cream
(one LEIC favorite and one Flavor of the Week)
-1 cookie ice cream sandwich
-1 artisan ice cream bar
-1 hand-made popsicle
-1 hot fudge packet
-1 pack of sprinkles
-A coupon for a free cone on your next visit!
$35 +