Selkirk Pizza is seriously one of the BEST pizza places around. I usually order for pickup, and it has become one of those places where I already know I'm going to be happy when I open the box. 😂 The pizza is consistently amazing! Great crust, plenty of toppings, and just genuinely GOOD pizza.
I've also eaten inside, and the setup is fantastic. They have a separate 21+ side with a bar and games, so you can actually hang out and have a completely different experience than just grabbing dinner. Then there's a separate all-ages side with an INCREDIBLE salad bar. And I don't throw around “incredible” for a salad bar. 😂
Whether you're going in to eat, hanging out on the 21+ side, bringing the family, or doing what I usually do and picking up a pizza to take home, this place delivers every time.
There are plenty of places where pizza is just pizza. Selkirk is NOT one of them. Their pizza is legitimately fantastic, and I will happily keep coming back. Absolutely deserves five stars.
D
Dianne J
Emerging Expert • 16 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/13/26
• DoorDash order
I notice Selkirk is closed, maybe after they prepared my delivery order tonight (just an hr ago) !? It was very sloppily put together. The garlic bread (had to toss away) was put in tin bowl on top of the way too soaked alfredo sauce on chewy undone noodles (*Bad quality). Too bad as the alfredo sauce could be very good. As the dish cooled the sauce turned into glue ! I'd heat it in microwave, but the dish is tin.
D
Desiree B
14 contributions
Liked
• 4/19/26
• DoorDash order
I tried ordering a half & half pizza with 1/2 SM Taco & 1/2 custom, with trying to use 1st & 2nd half and it didn't connect well with reach half as you have no clue which is what as you try to select.So,I called the restaurant to make thechanges since it came back weird. I ended up with a "Taco pizza" with no taco, just the extra olives and the white sauce that was to be on the byo. the byo had no sauce, not sure i got basil, no balsamic Drizzle. I told him what I wanted on each side since it looked wrong. he said he'd take notes, then looked at the order and said it matched... it did not.
What we did get was very tasty and I'd do again, though I did dip the pizza... I just wouldn't try to do a half & half again on door dash.
Chicken Alfredo Pasta was a hit with my friend, as well as the Garlic Cheese Bread
