Stuff A Bagel Menu
$$Sweets, Bagels, Lunch, Pickup
Get delivery or pickup from Stuff A Bagel when you order online with DoorDash
Stuff A Bagel Menu
Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest storeCategories
- Joey's
- Cream Cheese
- Stuffed Breakfast Bagels
- Stuffed Specialty Bagels
- 3 Egg Omelets
- Mario's Breakfast Special
- Healthier Choices
- Bakery
- Hot Lunch
- Cold Lunch
- Delicious Duos
- Salads and Sides
Joey's
Dozen Bagels (14)
Choose 14 from 17 flavors including asiago cheese, blueberry, cinnamon raisin, and sundried tomato. Bialy and whole wheat options available.
$24 +
Half Dozen Bagels
Choose 6 from 17 options including asiago cheese, daily special, and more. Selections range from classic plain to savory egg everything and sweet blueberry.
$14 +
Cream Cheese
Cream Cheese (1 Lb)
1 lb cream cheese with options: plain, low fat, or flavored spread. Choose from cinnamon raisin, jalapeño, maple walnut, scallion, strawberry, veggie, or olive lox flavors.
$10.99 +
Plain Cream Cheese
Plain cc on a bagel
$7 +
Butter & Cream Cheese
Butter & cc on a bagel
$7.25 +
Flavored Cream Cheese
On a bagel choose strawberry,maple walnut, cinnamon raisin, veggie, scallion, olive, jalapeno on a bagel
$7.5 +
Flavored Cream Cheese & Butter
Flavored cc & butter on a bagel choose what flavored cream cheese
$5.75 +
Butter
Butter on a bagel
$6.25 +
Peanut Butter
On a bagel
$6.25 +
Peanut Butter & Jelly
On a bagel
$6.5 +
Lox Spread
On a bagel
$9.99 +
Fresh Lox & Cream Cheese
Onions, capers and lettuce upon request.
$12.99 +
Stuffed Breakfast Bagels
2 Eggs
Two eggs served in your choice of bagel, roll, or wrap.
$9.15 +
2 Eggs with Cheese
Swiss, cheddar, American provolone or pepper jack.
$10.12 +
2 Eggs with Cheese
Swiss, cheddar, american provolone or pepper jack.
$9.75 +
2 Eggs with Lox
Two eggs and lox on your choice of bagel, roll, or wrap.
$13 +
Stuffed Specialty Bagels
LIE - Long Island Expressway
Two eggs, steak and cheese.
$10.75 +
Jersey Turnpike
Taylor ham, two eggs and cheese.
$13.05 +
BQE - Brooklyn Queens Expressway
Two eggs, potatoes and cheese.
$10.75 +
Southern State
Two eggs, turkey and cheese.
$10.75 +
Frank the Tank
$11.75 +
Burrito
Two eggs scrambled with peppers, onions, sausage and cheese.
$11.1 +
3 Egg Omelets
Cheese
Three eggs whisked together, typically includes a generous amount of melted cheese.
$12 +
Ham with Cheese
Three eggs enveloping diced ham and melted cheese, traditionally prepared as a folded omelet.
$13.5 +
Bacon with Cheese
Three eggs omelet filled with crispy bacon and a blend of cheeses, typically including cheddar.
$13.5 +
Sausage with Cheese
Served with a buttered bagel.
$13.5 +
Western
Three eggs combined with diced ham, bell peppers, and onions, typically enveloped in a fluffy omelette.
$13 +
Mario's Breakfast Special
Mario's Breakfast Special
Two eggs, choice of ham, bacon or sausage with cheese, home fries, buttered bagel and coffee.
$14.99 +
Healthier Choices
Garden State Omelet
Four egg whites, assorted veggies, swiss cheese on a buttered whole wheat bagel.
$12.15 +
Lean Burrito
Two egg whites, turkey, peppers, onions with cheese.
$11.5 +
Bakery
Danish
Cherry cheese, blueberry cheese or plain cheese.
$6 +
Turnovers
Apple, cherry, blueberry.
$5.75 +
Crumbcake
A soft, buttery cake base typically topped with a generous layer of cinnamon streusel crumbs.
$6.5 +
Black & White Cookies
Soft, cake-like cookies featuring a harmonious blend of vanilla and chocolate icing on each half.
$5.74 +
Assorted Muffins
An assortment of freshly baked muffins, typically including flavors such as corn, blueberry, banana nut, and chocolate chip.
$6 +
Cinnamon Bun
Soft, spiral pastry topped with creamy, sweet frosting and a sprinkle of cinnamon.
$6.25 +
Chocolate Croissant
Buttery croissant filled with rich, melted chocolate.
$7.25 +
Cannoli
Seasonal.
$6 +
Assorted Italian Cookies (1 Lb)
Rainbow, linzer tarte pink and green leaf. *
*Seasonal
$13.99 +
Hot Lunch
Ham & Cheese Melt
With butter and garlic spread.
$13.99 +
Turkey & Cheese Melt
With russian dressing.
$13.99 +
Roast Beef & Cheese Melt
With butter and garlic spread.
$13.99 +
Pastrami & Cheese Melt
With sauerkraut and spicy mustard.
$13.99 +
Reuben
Corned beef and swiss with sauerkraut and Russian dressing.
$13.99 +
Turkey Reuben
Turkey, swiss, sauerkraut and Russian dressing.
$13.99 +
Philly Cheese Steak
Seasoned beef with provolone, peppers, onions and mayo.
$13.99 +
Cold Lunch
Turkey Supreme
Turkey, swiss, bacon, lettuce, tomato, onion with Russian dressing.
$12.99 +
BLT
Bacon, lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$11.5 +
Lisa's Famous Chicken Salad
With lettuce, tomato and mayo.
$12.5 +
Tony Tuna Teaser
Tuna, cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion.
$12.5 +
Farm Fresh Egg Salad
Farm fresh egg salad served on your choice of bagel, roll, or wrap.
$12.5 +
Delicious Duos
Sandwich & Salad
Choose from signature sandwiches: Jersey Turnpike, LIE - Long Island Expressway, Reuben. Paired with a side salad: Chicken Salad, Lisa's Famous Chicken Salad, or Macaroni Salad.
$14.74 +
Salads and Sides
Chicken Salad (1 Lb)
Homemade chicken salad typically includes diced chicken breast, celery, and mayonnaise.
$14.99 +
Tuna Salad (1 Lb)
Albacore tuna blended with celery, mayo, and a hint of seasoning, creating a classic tuna salad.
$14.99 +
Egg Salad (1 Lb)
Chopped hard-boiled eggs blended with mayonnaise, mustard, and a hint of seasoning.
$13.99 +
Macaroni Salad (1 Lb)
Elbow macaroni mixed with mayonnaise, diced celery, onions, and sweet pickles, seasoned with salt and pepper.
$9.99 +
Whitefish Salad (1 Lb)
Whitefish salad typically consists of smoked whitefish combined with mayonnaise and other seasonings, often garnished with fresh herbs.
$17.99 +
Bacon
Crispy, smoked bacon strips with a rich, savory flavor.
$6.75 +
Sausage
Savory, perfectly seasoned sausage links, a classic breakfast favorite.
$6.75 +
Ham
Tender, savory sliced pork, perfectly cured and gently seasoned for a classic taste.
$6.75 +
Turkey
Turkey, cheddar cheese, coleslaw, and Russian dressing on a bed of lettuce, typically includes tomatoes and cucumbers.
$7 +
Pork Roll
Pork roll typically includes thinly sliced pork, often combined with spices and herbs, rolled and served as a savory side dish.
$7 +