The Bagelry Menu
$$Bagels, Pickup, Takeout
Get delivery or pickup from The Bagelry when you order online with DoorDash
The Bagelry Menu
Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest storeCategories
- Bagels & Spreads
- Beverages
- Egg Sandwiches
- Bagel Sandwiches
- Sides
Bagels & Spreads
Single Bagel
*We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day.
$2.25 +
Bagel and Butter
$3 +
Single Bagel & Spread
*We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day. If you'd like a bagel with butter, please select 'Single Bagel' and add Butter.
$4.75 +
Half Dozen Bagels
Please indicate in the Notes section during Checkout which counts of each bagel you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
$12 +
Dozen Bagels
Please indicate in the Notes section during Checkout which counts of each bagel you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
$21 +
Brunch Bundle
A dozen bagels with 2 tubs of cream cheese. Please indicate in the Notes section during Checkout which counts of each bagel you'd like. We'll do our best to accommodate but please be aware that we may run out of bagels and substitute with other flavors.
$30 +
Cream Cheese (2 oz.)
An individual 2oz. container of our housemade cream cheese.
$2.25 +
Cream Cheese (8 oz.)
8 oz. tub of our housemade cream cheese.
$6 +
Vegan Spread (8 oz.)
8 oz. tub of our housemade vegan cashew spread.
$9.5 +
Beverages
Coffee - Small (12 oz.)
Tinker Coffee Indianapolis, Single Origin Nicaragua
$3.5 +
Coffee - Large (16 oz.)
Tinker Coffee Indianapolis, Single Origin Nicaragua
$4.25 +
Hot Chocolate
Ghirardelli hot chocolate. 12oz cup.
$3.5 +
Apple Juice
Tropicana
$4.25 +
Orange Juice
Tropicana Low Pulp
$4.25 +
Bottled Water
16.9 oz. bottle
$1.25 +
La Croix Seltzer Water
12 oz. can
$1.75 +
Bottled Tea - Sweetened
$3.5 +
Bottled Tea - Unsweetened
$3.5 +
Coffee Box
96 oz. cardboard coffee clutch. Single Origin, Malawi, Tinker Coffee, Indianapolis, IN
$36 +
Egg Sandwiches
BYO Egg Sandwich
Fresh cracked scrambled egg on your choice of bagel. Option to add cheese, meat, and/or veggies!
*We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor. Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
$6 +
Bacon Avocado
Egg, bacon, avocado, and sriracha on your choice of bagel.
If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away!
Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
$10.25 +
The GECCO
Goetta, Egg, Cheddar, and Chive & Onion cream cheese on your choice of bagel.
If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away!
Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
$10.75 +
Southwestern
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, Avril Bleh sausage, pepperjack cheese, jalapeno garlic cream cheese, banana peppers, and red onions on your choice of bagel.
If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away!
$11 +
Queen City
Fresh cracked scrambled egg, Glier's goetta, and American cheese on your choice of bagel.
If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away!
Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
$9.5 +
The Garden
Fresh crackled scrambled egg, Swiss cheese, roasted vegetable cream cheese, lettuce, onion, tomato, and red bell pepper on your choice of bagel.
If you'd like to make substitutions, please instead choose the BYO Breakfast and customize away!
Breakfast sandwiches are "toasted" by default. Please only select Double Toasted if you like your bagel very dark.
$9.5 +
The Skillet
A whole diner breakfast piled on a bagel! Fresh cracked scrambled egg, bacon, American cheese, a hash brown, and ketchup on your choice of bagel.
$11.25 +
Bagel Sandwiches
NYC Lox
Brooklyn-based Acme lox, onion, tomato, capers, and plain cream cheese. *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
$13 +
Smoked Turkey
Lucius Q smoked turkey, housemade onion chive cream cheese, lettuce, and tomato on your choice of bagel. Option to add bacon for the full club experience!
$9 +
Avocado Bagel Toast
Sliced avocado, sea salt, red pepper flakes, onion, and tomato on your choice of bagel.
$9.25 +
Italian
Ham, pepperoni, jalapeno garlic cream cheese, onion, tomato, and banana peppers. *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
$9 +
BLT
Double bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on your choice of bagel.
$8 +
Pizza Bagel
Garlic butter, pizza sauce, provolone, and Italian seasoning. Option to add pepperoni and/or banana peppers. *We'll do our best to accommodate your bagel flavor, but please note that we run out of certain flavors during the day and may default to a plain bagel if we're out of your selected flavor.
$7.5 +
Sides
2 oz. Lox
A single portion of lox from Acme in Brooklyn, NY.
$7 +
Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie
A Massachusetts original brought to the next level in Cincinnati using premium chocolate and browned butter.
$3.5 +
Miss Vickie's Chips
$2 +
Hash Brown
One crispy hash brown patty
$2.25 +