Kelleher's Irish Pub is a purveyor of superb Irish food and wonderful libations, located on Peoria's picturesque Water Street. Kelleher's Irish Pub first opened its doors in May 2001 and has since bec…
Shepherd's pie was really great. There was enough for 2 meals. I will definitely order that again. It was full of meat and veggies and vert flavorful. My order was delivered quickly.
C
Cheryle H
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 29/04/23
• DoorDash order
My corned beef sandwich was not piled high with corned beef as described. Bread was greasy and the meat dry. Waffle friesalso super greasy and chewy. Definitely a disappoint when Iwas all set for tender, moist, piled high sandwich. Worst meal for $25 total
S
Stacy v
Emerging Expert • 21 contributions
Didn't like
• 04/01/22
• DoorDash order
I was hoping for a really amazing Irish shepherd's pie, flavorful soup, creamy, buttery mashed potatoes, & delicious warm bread. Unfortunately I was fairly disappointed with my entire meal. The mashed potatoes were fine but the soup was just fair...just not anything special. (I hate to say this but Panera's...a CHAIN restaurant...is better). My biggest disappointment was the shepherd's pie & the soda bread. The shepherd's pie was really, really bland. I shouldn't have to add things to make it have more taste. It needed salt really bad for one thing & absolutely needed more seasoning. I've had shepherd's pie quite a few times at different Irish pubs & I've also made it myself a few times. None of them were this bland. There was plenty of meat & veg but they just weren't seasoned. The soda bread was bad enough we couldn't eat it. It went out to the birds. It was just gross. I hate to leave remarks like this, especially about a family owned establishment, but if they don't recieve honest feedback they won't know there's an issue & can't work on fixing it. These things can be fixed & I really hope they do. I never want to see a business like this fold-up for any reason...but especially over things that can be remedied. I won't be ordering from here again unless I hear they've turned things around. I don't think they were just having a bad night since there was 3 items that were just not good. If it was just one...then maybe it was just an oversight while preparing it, but 3 things in one order seems pretty consistent. I really hope things are improved soon.
N
Nick M
1 contributions
Loved
• 08/10/23
• DoorDash order
I ordered the Irish Sampler. It was delicious! The chicken hot pot (very similar to chicken pot pie) was very tasty. My favorite was the coddle, which is like if loaded mashed potatoes were made into a soup. My partner's fave was the Shepherd's Pie. We'd get this again in a minute. Very happy we ate here!
B
Ben H
1 contributions
Loved
• 15/01/24
• DoorDash order
I tries the Beef Bites on a recommendation and had no clue what I was getting it's an open faced sandwich it's wonderful with a side of fries. I'll be adding this to my rotation of wonderful meals I've had from Kelleher's.
