We were so disappointed in the Judge's Sampler tonight. It used to be enough for four people, but the food that was actually eatable was enough for two or three. The pulled pork was so little and just a hunk of fat (see photo). While there were a lot of ribs, they were dry and over done. It was like eating beef jerky. We noticed the price increased $10, which I understand food costs rising, but to also have less product was really disappointing.
N
Nicholas S
Local Expert • 240 contributions
Loved
• 3/06/24
• DoorDash order
Pulled Pork was perfect, as were the Green Beans with Bacon and Creamy Slaw . It's hard to beat this place in terms of quality for price. My order is also always accurate, and everything arrives fresh/warm.
B
Bryan E
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4 days ago
• DoorDash order
Let's start with the $35 Three Meats, Two Sides a total of 7 little pieces of pork belly for $4 extra was ridiculous and then we can discuss the extra dry brisket. Almost inedible. The smoked sausage was decent but I asked for swine sauce and got just original bbq sauce. Now for the $7 Banana Pudding that was more Carmel than banana pudding was completely inedible I can't believe that city bbq has dropped there standards this low. This will be the last order from me. Hopefully others have a better experience but for $50 it was nothing good.
S
Samantha M
4 contributions
Liked
• 21/02/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered the Pitmaster Nachos with 2 sides, corn pudding and potato salad. The star of the show was the corn pudding, best I've ever had! The potato salad was good. The nachos when I first opened them I said "WTF" out loud out of disappointment. The food was hot and fresh, but there was a HUGE lack of meat. It said this is a "shareable" but there no way this is enough for more than one person. The second photo looks AMAZING because I spent 10 minutes ripping up each bite of meat, tomatoes ETC to cover it. There was still only enough to cover the top layer of nachos. I'd order from here again, but I wouldn't spend $25 on a few nachos I'd order a bigger meal for the same price. . . AND CORN PUDDING!
T
Tamara J
14 contributions
Liked
• 16/07/25
• DoorDash order
The price for 6 wings in comparison to how awfully small they were was very disappointing to me. I did not get value for my money. As such, I will no longer be ordering wings from this establishment but rather will order from other restaurants.
