As its name suggests, this pizza joint specializes in tomato pie — a saucy square-pan pizza born in Philly that’s dressed in marinara, Romano cheese, parsley, and olive oil, but no mozzarella. It’s a …
Great pizza. Very crispy as I requested, ZERO FLOP JUST AS HOW I LIK IT!!! The Wings are also phenomenal!!!
S
Sebastian W
Local Expert • 50 contributions
Loved
• 9/08/25
• DoorDash order
This place has become my fave New York pizza style. It's so effing good. Have been ordering multiple times. My go to is the Medium Cheese with mushroom, pep, onions, oregano, Romano cheese, well done. It is the bomb! The Meatballs (2) are incredible as well. Super fresh and super tasty.
S
Sebastian W
Local Expert • 50 contributions
Loved
• 5/08/25
• DoorDash order
Typically I'm a Detroit style pizza guy, but their regular pizza is prob one of my faves. Really great crispy crust, good sauce, cheese is excellent and toppings are tasty. I also got a Meat Calzone which was really tasty, big, and plentiful. I'll keep reordering from here.
C
Charmaine G
Local Expert • 38 contributions
Liked
• 8/12/25
• DoorDash order
Medium Cheese pizza was delicious. The NY Cheesecake however was the tiniest slice of cheesecake I'd ever seen lol. NOT worth the $7. It was literally like 4 bites.
G
Gloria W
1 contributions
Loved
• 5/01/26
• DoorDash order
Tried Tomato Pie Pizza while visiting in Woodland Hills. It said NY style pizza and I was skeptical since we were in the outskirts of LA. But it did not disappoint. In fact, it was exceptionally good. True to California form, there were plenty of vegetarian options. I tried Mr. White and Miss Green both were very tasty.
The service was okay... blah the first visit but much friendlier on the second visit. It's not an "order your pizza, sit down and enjoy it" kind of place. There are only one or two tables. So it's more of an order your pizza, pick it up and bring it home to enjoy spot. They also have pizza by the slice.
Two thumbs up. I'm going back today to try something with meat this time.
