Buttercooky Bakery & Café Menu

$$Cupcakes, Pastries, Bakery, Cookies

Get delivery or pickup from Buttercooky Bakery & Café when you order online with DoorDash

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Menu

Prices are estimated based on your predicted location and may vary across store, enter address for menu prices at your nearest store

Fall Favorites

Fall Themed Cupcake

$6.95 +

Fall Themed Cake Pop

$3.95 +

Pumpkin Cheesecake Slice

$8.95 +

Pumpkin & Salted Caramel Pastry

A buttery vanilla sable cookie topper with delicate vanilla cake, salted caramel and cream pumpkin. finished with a silky chocolate glaze and artfully crafted to resemble a pumpkin

$9.95 +

Pumpkin Pie

$27 +

Vanilla Pumpkin Cream Cake with Chocolate Glaze

$39.95 +

Showcase Cakes

Strawberry Shortcake

Pillowy-soft whipped cream loaded with freshly chopped strawberries set atop thin layers of vanilla cake lightly soaked in strawberry syrup, garnished with vanilla chantilly cream and fresh strawberries

$36 +

Funfetti Cake

Smooth and silky vanilla buttercream set atop thin layers of funfetti cake baked golden and moist, finished with a wave of funfetti colors and lathered in funfetti sprinkles

$35 +

Large Fruit Torte

Pastry shell lined with chocolate and vanilla custard topped with fresh fruit

$47.5 +

4" Vanilla Mini Birthday Cake

Sweet vanilla buttercream set atop thin layers of moist vanilla cake iced in smooth vanilla buttercream, garnished with colorful buttercream balloons and funfetti sprinkles

$17.45 +

Small 7 Layer Cake

Seven thin layers of Vanilla Cake alternating with a thin layer of Chocolate Buttercream and topped with hard chocolate icing

$16.5 +

Black Forest Cake

Chocolate cake filled with chocolate whipped cream and black cherries, topped with cherries, whipped cream and chocolate shavings

$35 +

Checkerboard Log Cake

Creamy chocolate fudge sandwiched between alternating layers of moist vanilla and chocolate cake creating a checkerboard pattern, finished with rich chocolate buttercream icing and chocolate cake crumbs Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$34.95 +

Breakfast Pastries

Chocolate Cigar

(puff pastry dough)

$5.95 +

Crumb Cake Slice

Soft, moist cake topped with a generous layer of sweet, buttery crumb, dusted with powdered sugar.

$4.05 +

Corn Muffin

Golden-brown corn muffin with a slightly crisp exterior and a moist, tender crumb.

$5.65 +

Peach Boat

Flaky pastry filled with caramelized peach slices.

$6.85 +

Blueberry Muffin

Bursting with blueberries and topped with a crumbly streusel, this muffin offers a sweet, fruity bite.

$5.65 +

Russian Tea Cake

Rich chocolate center encased in a crumbly, golden-brown pastry, topped with delicate, piped meringue, and dipped in a smooth, dark chocolate coating.

$6.25 +

Railroad Bar

Layers of flaky pastry with a sweet fruit filling, topped with sliced almonds.

$7.45 +

Cheese Danish

Flaky pastry filled with creamy cheese, featuring a golden-brown, buttery exterior.

$6.55 +

Almond Cheese Danish

Flaky pastry filled with creamy cheese and topped with sliced almonds.

$6.6 +

8" Pies & Mini Pies

8" Pecan Pie

Rich, buttery filling topped with toasted pecans in a flaky, golden crust.

$36.1 +

8" Coconut Custard Pie

$28.75 +

8" Old Fashioned Apple Pie

$28.75 +

Mini Pecan Pie

Rich, buttery crust filled with a sweet, gooey mixture of caramelized pecans.

$10 +

Mini Key Lime Pie

Creamy key lime pie filling set atop the most wonderful crunchy, sweet and buttery bed of graham cracker crust, finished with whipped cream and decorative lime sugar pieces.

$8.75 +

Croissants

Biscoff Croissant

Biscoff Filling inside topped with biscoff cookie

$9 +

Chocolate Croissant

Flaky, golden-brown pastry with a rich, chocolate filling.

$9 +

Plain Croissant

Layers of golden, flaky pastry with a light, buttery interior.

$6.2 +

Pain Au Raisins

Raisin and Vanilla Creme Patissiere Croissant

$9 +

Pain Au Suisse Croissant

Layers of buttery pastry filled with a rich vanilla custard and dark chocolate pieces.

$9 +

Guava and Cheese Croissant

$9 +

Sweet Treats Ready 2 Go

2 Pound Assorted Butter Cookie Tray

A variety of butter cookies, including classic shapes and flavors, totaling two pounds.

$67.8 +

5 Pound Cookie Tray

$148.25 +

Double Chocolate Chip Biscotti Bag

$33.5 +

Dark Cherry Biscotti Bag

$33.5 +

Traditional Biscotti Bag

$33.5 +

1/2 LB Anise Drops

$20 +

1/2 lb Pefeffernusse

$24.95 +

1lb Sugar Free Cookies

$26.95 +

Mousse Cakes

Tres Leche

Silky smooth custard cream and dulce de leche set atop ultra-moist vanilla sponge famous for being soaked in our specially crafted 3-milk mixture blend, iced with pillowy-soft whipped cream and topped with fresh strawberries, peaches, raspberries, blackberries, and blueberries

$47.75 +

Small Tres Leche

$12.35 +

Red Velvet Mousse

Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop thin layers of moist velvet cake coated in smooth cream cheese icing, finished with ruby red chocolate ganache drip, vanilla buttercream, and red velvet cake crumbs

$46.45 +

Hazelnut Chocolate Mousse

Hazelnut and chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft chocolate cake, finished with rich chocolate ganache, hazelnut whipped ganache, chocolate triangles and toasted hazelnuts

$46.45 +

Silk & Satin Mousse

Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous NY style cheesecake set atop a thin moist chocolate cake, finished with a nest of chocolate ganache, gold dusted lines and lathered in roasted almond slices

$46.45 +

Traditional Tiramisu

Light and airy mascarpone cheese layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger vanilla cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a low peak of vanilla whipped cream dusted with cocoa powder and enclosed with lady fingers.

$46.45 +

Pistachio & Black Forest Mousse

Pistachio mousse and cherry cremeux set atop a thin moist vanilla cake, lightly soaked in cherry syrup finished with pistachio glaze, garnished with dollops of vanilla whipped ganache, toasted pistachio nuts and fresh cherries

$46.45 +

Vanilla Chocolate Mousse

Light and airy chocolate mousse set atop a thin layer of soft vanilla cake glazed with rich chocolate ganache, topped with mountainous vanilla creme and white chocolate crunchies Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$46.45 +

Large Fruit Torte

Pastry shell lined with chocolate and vanilla custard topped with fresh fruit

$47.5 +

Bread/Bagels

Plain Bagel

Golden-brown bagel with a chewy texture and a subtly crisp crust.

$2.2 +

Everything Bagel

A dense, chewy bagel topped with a mix of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and salt.

$2.2 +

Sesame Bagel

A chewy, golden-brown bagel topped with a generous sprinkling of sesame seeds.

$2.2 +

Plain Roll

Soft, golden-brown bread roll with a slightly crisp crust and tender, fluffy interior.

$1.25 +

Poppy Roll

Golden-brown bread roll topped with a generous sprinkle of crunchy poppy seeds.

$1.25 +

Sesame Roll

A soft, golden-brown roll generously topped with toasted sesame seeds.

$1.25 +

Egg Roll

Crispy and flavorful roll filled with egg and a savory blend of ingredients.

$1.25 +

French Baguette

$3.75 +

Rye Bread

$7.85 +

Semolina Bread

$3.75 +

Savory Bites

Spinach and Cheese Quiche

Savory Croissant filled with spinach and gruyere and cheddar cheese

$12.5 +

Broccoli and Gruyere Cheese Quiche

$12.5 +

Quiche Lorraine (Ham & Cheese)

$12.5 +

Ham and Swiss Croissant

$12.5 +

Turkey and Gouda Cheese Croissant

$12.5 +

Brownies & Donuts

Jelly Donut

Soft and fluffy donut filled with sweet jelly, lightly dusted with granulated sugar.

$5.6 +

Glazed Vanilla Donut

Soft, fluffy donut with a sweet vanilla glaze.

$3.15 +

Vanilla French Cruller

Light and airy pastry with a delicate vanilla glaze.

$3.15 +

Oreo Brownie

Rich brownie topped with crushed Oreo cookies and a dusting of powdered sugar.

$7.2 +

Chocolate French Cruller

Delicate, airy cruller donut coated in rich, smooth chocolate glaze.

$3.15 +

Pecan Brownie

Rich chocolate brownie topped with a generous layer of crunchy pecans.

$7.2 +

Fudge Brownie

Rich, dense brownie with a smooth, glossy fudge topping, offering a decadent chocolate experience in every bite.

$5.95 +

DUBAI CHOCOLATE TREATS <3

The Dubai Chocolate Croissant

Pistachio & Kunafa Filling

$9.25 +

The Dubai Chocolate Donut

Pistachio & Kunafa Filling

$8 +

The Dubai Chocolate Cannoli

Cannoli with Pistachio and Kunafa filling dipped in chocolate

$9.95 +

The Dubai Chocolate Brownie

$11.25 +

The Dubai Chocolate Mousse Cake

Chocolate Sponge, Dark Chocolate Mousse, Chocolate Ganache filled with Pistachio and Kunafa— the Dubai chocolate specialty

$47.75 +

Rings/Horns

Large Chocolate Horn

Buttery, flaky pastry horn generously dusted with powdered sugar and drizzled with rich chocolate.

$19 +

Large Pecan Ring

Topped with pecans and drizzled with icing, this large ring-shaped pastry offers a sweet and nutty flavor.

$19 +

Large Hard Icing Apple Horn

Golden-brown pastry horn filled with apple and topped with a layer of hard icing.

$19 +

Large Apple Crumb Horn

Flaky pastry horn filled with sweet apple filling, topped with a generous layer of crumb topping and dusted with powdered sugar.

$19 +

Large Fruit Ring

A large ring-shaped pastry topped with assorted fruit preserves and drizzled with white icing.

$19 +

Powdered Almond Horn Horn

Dusted with powdered sugar, this almond horn features a crisp exterior and a soft, nutty interior.

$7.2 +

Chocolate Dipped Almond Horn

Covered in crunchy almond slices and dipped in rich chocolate, this almond horn offers a delightful combination of textures and flavors.

$7.2 +

Individual Slices

Carrot Cake Slice

Moist carrot cake slice with a creamy frosting, topped with a decorative carrot-shaped icing.

$7.45 +

Napoleon Slice

Layers of crisp puff pastry, creamy custard, and a light glaze with chocolate drizzle.

$7.45 +

Tiramisu Slice

Layers of coffee-soaked sponge cake and mascarpone cheese, dusted with cocoa powder.

$8.25 +

7-Layer Cake Slice

Rich, moist layers of yellow cake interspersed with smooth chocolate frosting, finished with a glossy chocolate glaze.

$7.45 +

Cheesecakes

7" Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$33.45 +

Individual NY Cheesecake (Gluten Free)

Smooth and silky cream cheese (gluten-free).

$6.25 +

Raspberry Cheesecake French Pastry

New York Style Cheesecake set atop of graham cracker crust with a raspberry preserve on top and garnished with fresh raspberries

$8.45 +

Individual Strawberry Cheesecake (Gluten Free)

Smooth and silky cream cheese finished with fluffy whipped cream and a fresh strawberry (gluten-free).

$8.1 +

7" Chocolate Fudge Cheesecake

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$31 +

7" Oreo Cheesecake

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$32 +

10" Chocolate Fudge Cheesecake

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$55.3 +

10" Strawberry Cheesecake

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$67.8 +

7" Italian Cheesecake

Creamy Italian cheesecake with a golden-brown crust, topped with a powdered sugar lattice pattern.

$37.45 +

Cupcakes

Pink Rose Cupcake Vanilla

$4.75 +

Pink Rose Cupcake Chocolate

$4.75 +

Rainbow Cookie Cupcake Vanilla

A vanilla cupcake topped with a rainbow cookie piece, adorned with colorful sprinkles.

$4.75 +

Minnie Mouse Cupcake Vanilla

Vanilla cupcake topped with pink buttercream, chocolate cookie ears, and a pink bow-shaped fondant.

$4.75 +

Spiderman Cupcake Vanilla

Vanilla cupcake adorned with red sprinkles, blue web icing, and white eyes, inspired by Spiderman.

$4.75 +

Mickey Mouse Cupcake Chocolate

Rich chocolate cupcake topped with vibrant red frosting, adorned with mini chocolate cookies and yellow candy buttons.

$4.75 +

Cookie Monster Cupcake Vanilla

Vanilla cupcake topped with blue frosting, featuring large candy eyes and a cookie for a playful design.

$4.75 +

Elmo Cupcake Vanilla

Vanilla cupcake topped with red frosting, a cookie mouth, and candy eyes and nose, resembling a playful character.

$4.75 +

Elmo Cupcake Chocolate

Rich chocolate cupcake topped with red icing, an orange candy nose, and an Oreo cookie mouth, resembling a playful character.

$4.75 +

Vanilla Classic Cupcake

Soft vanilla cupcake topped with smooth white frosting, colorful sprinkles, and a cherry.

$4.75 +

Cake Pops

Vanilla Cake Pop

A round vanilla cake pop coated in white chocolate with decorative white sprinkles.

$3.7 +

Funfetti Cake Pop

Covered in white chocolate and adorned with colorful sprinkles, this funfetti cake pop offers a bite-sized treat with a burst of sweetness.

$3.7 +

Red Velvet Cake Pop

Covered in a red velvet crumb coating, this cake pop offers a bite-sized indulgence of moist red velvet cake on a convenient stick.

$3.7 +

Chocolate Cake Pop

Rich chocolate cake pop coated in smooth chocolate and topped with chocolate sprinkles.

$3.7 +

Oreo Cake Pop

Coated in white chocolate and topped with crushed Oreo cookies, this cake pop offers a delightful blend of creamy and crunchy textures.

$3.7 +

French Pastries, Tarts, Eclairs

Red Velvet French Pastry

Pillowy-soft cream cheese set atop a thin moist velvet cake, finished with a dollop of fluffy cream cheese frosting.

$8.45 +

Oreo Mousse French Pastry

Rich and creamy cookies n' cream loaded with chunks of oreo set atop a buttery oreo sablé cookie, finished with vanilla whipped ganache and studded with vanilla & dark chocolate shards

$8.45 +

Silk & Satin French Pastry

Silky chocolate mousse infused with our famous New York style cheesecake set atop a buttery chocolate shortbread cookie, finished with chocolate ganache and lightly lathered in chocolate cake crumbs.

$8.45 +

Chocolate Tiramisu French Pastry

Light and airy chocolate mascarpone cheese loaded with chunks of chocolate chips layered with ever-so-soft moist lady finger chocolate cake soaked in freshly brewed espresso coffee and a hint of coffee syrup, finished with a dark chocolate curl & chocolate cake crumbs.

$8.45 +

Apple Crumble Tart

Freshly diced apples doused in our special cinnamon sugar blend resting in a vanilla sable tart shell topped with baked golden buttery crumble

$9.75 +

Chocolate Cannoli

Crispy fried shell dipped in chocolate filled with sweet ricotta cheese and chocolate chip, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar

$6.2 +

Bread Pudding

Rich, decadent pudding with a warm, fluffy texture, served with a creamy sauce.

$7 +

Creme Brulee

Slowly baked custard cream perfectly doused in sugar that is torched to a golden brittle crust finished with an assortment of fresh berries.

$9 +

Vanilla Bean French Tartlet

Almond cake lightly soaked in almond praline syrup with vanilla creme anglaise in a buttery vanilla sable tart, topped with vanilla bean mousse & garnished with white chocolate, chopped toasted almonds, and gold leaf

$9.75 +

Large Cookies & Sweets

Linzer Tart Cookie

Buttery cookie filled with sweet raspberry jam, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar.

$6.2 +

Chocolate Chip Cookie

Rich, golden-brown cookie studded with semi-sweet chocolate chips.

$5.65 +

M&M Cookie

A large cookie studded with colorful M&M candies, offering a sweet and crunchy bite in every mouthful.

$5.65 +

Chocolate Sprinkle Cookie

Covered in chocolate sprinkles, this large cookie offers a delightful crunch with every bite.

$5.65 +

Sugar Cookie

A large, round sugar cookie with a crisp edge and a generous sprinkle of sugar on top.

$5.65 +

Plain Chinese Cookie

Delicate, crumbly cookie topped with a rich chocolate center.

$5.6 +

Chocolate Marble Chinese Cookie

Swirled vanilla and chocolate cookie topped with a rich chocolate center.

$5.6 +

Oatmeal Raisin Cookie

A hearty oatmeal cookie featuring chewy raisins, offering a classic blend of wholesome oats and sweet dried fruit.

$5.65 +

Black & White Cookie

A large cookie with one half coated in rich chocolate icing and the other half in sweet vanilla icing.

$5.95 +

Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie

A soft, round cookie generously covered in colorful rainbow sprinkles.

$5.65 +

Coffee / Espresso/ Tea / Hot Coco

Small Hot Chocolate

$4.4 +

Large Hot Chocolate

$6.9 +

Small Hot Coffee

$3.75 +

Large Hot Coffee

$4.95 +

Small Hot Latte

$6.25 +

Small Brown Sugar Oat Milk Draft Latte

$8.7 +

Double Espresso

Rich, bold double shot espresso, perfectly concentrated for a robust coffee experience.

$5.15 +

Small Iced Macchiato

$5.65 +

Large Iced Macchiato

$6.2 +

Small Hot Macchiato

$4.4 +

Candles

Number 1 Candle

$5.3 +

Number 2 Candle

$5.3 +

Number 5 Candle

$5.3 +

Number 7 Candle

$5.3 +

Number 9 Candle

$5.3 +

Number 0 Candle

$5.3 +

Gold "Happy Birthday" Letter Candles

$5.3 +

16 Packaged White, Light Blue, Dark Blue, Gold Candles

$5.3 +

10 Packaged Gold Spiral Candles

$5.3 +

Multi-Color Balloon Candles

$5.3 +

Custom Order (Cake, Bread, Cupcakes, Cookies, ETC...)

CUSTOM PICK-UP ORDER ONLY

Please note: This is SOLEY for custom orders (items that were already purchased through our custom order department) that are unable to be picked up by the customer themselves - call store (via phone [516-354-3831]) to confirm custom cake is ready for pick up before purchasing this option. This option is NOT for purchasing store items, as the order will not be fulfilled. Please provide us with the following information: 1) Full name on order form 2) Invoice Number 3) Brief description of order details

$10 +

Easter Treats

Chocolate Cannoli

Crispy fried shell dipped in chocolate filled with sweet ricotta cheese and chocolate chip, topped with a dusting of powdered sugar

$6.2 +

10" Strawberry Cheesecake

Please indicate inscription in special instructions MUST click "Add Writing Chocolate Plaque"

$67.8 +

St. Joseph's Day/ Irish Soda Bread

Sfinge St Joseph Pastry

Zeppole filled with Cannoli Cream

$7.95 +

St. Patrick Day Cupcake

$5.95 +

St. Patrick Day Cake

Vanilla Cake Chocolate Fudge Filling St. Patrick Day Themed

$36.95 +

St. Patrick Day Cookie

$7.5 +

Father's Day Dessert

1 Pound Rainbow Cookies

$34.95 +

Similar Businesses

The Ice Cream Shop Buddy V's Cake Slice Cold Stone Creamery Grocery Outlet It's Just Wings Baskin-Robbins Edible Del Taco Cinnabon Rita's Italian Ice Subway 7-Eleven Dairy Queen Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers Great American Cookies

Buttercooky Bakery & Café Menu