Proper Pizza of Idaho
4.4(200+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info•
DashPass
Temporarily closed
4.4(200+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
24" Margharita
$28.99
24" Italian Job
$34.99
24" Peperoni
$32.99
24" Mushroom Pizza
$29.99
24" Hawaiian
$32.99
16" Proper Pizza
$20.99
Reviews200+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.4
of 5 stars
T
Taryn G
1 contributionsLoved
• 12/2/24We ordered the SPECIAL DEAL they are offering right now which I thought was a great price and plenty of food for our fam of 4 (two adults and two kiddos). We chose the proper pizza and were re pleased. The sesame seeds on the crust is delish---the crust is thinner which is our preference. We will definitely order from here again. I am excited to try more types of pizza.
J
Jake E
2 contributionsLoved
• 11/8/25The pepperoni pizza was great and pefectly cooked; real, squeaky, high quality cheese, the crust was perfectly chewy without being underdone. One of my new favorite places. Phenomenal size and quality for the price.
J
Jordan B
4 contributionsLoved
• 5/26/24This place is awesome and one of my favorite spots to order from. It's very consistent, and all of the pizzas (except the tuna) are great! The Macho and Idaho Potato are favorites, and the Cheeseburger is a sleeper (when the lettuce is crunchy it is fantastic, and it's great cold as leftovers just don't try to warm it back up).
Nutella Crunch is also great. Unlike most pizza place desserts that just reuse some form of their pizza dough for desserts, this had a thin and flaky almost graham cracker wafer paper type of crust that goes really well with the sweet toppings.
Ordered from here tons of times and will continue to - not sure why there aren't more 5 stars honestly!
K
Kim S
1 contributionsLoved
• 9/16/25Oh my goodness! When I first walked in I was amazed! It's such a welcoming, clean, environment! Did not expect it! The girl that waited on me had only been there 2 weeks and said she loved her job! I can see why! When I got home the pizza was a piece of art and when we tasted it, it was amazing!! We loved the thin sesame seed crust! I'm making this place one of my favs! You won't be disappointed!
S
Scooter S
2 contributionsLoved
• 8/11/25Awesome and great personal service!amazing pizzaswith great ingredients and fresh goodness in every bite. Big portions, highly recommend! I'd order again! Fresh meat and cheeses with fresh ingredients!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store