These cookies are top tier! The portions are perfect, I love sweets and surprisingly I couldn't finish them all in one sitting. I tried the pumpkin chocolate chip, cookies & cream, rainbow sugar, and the maple frosted one. 4 days ago I tried lions cub for the first time and tried the chocolate chip, snickerdoodle, frosted maple, and another frosted one . Once my sweet tooth hit today I had to order them for the second time to try more flavors. I'll forsure order these again to try the rest of the flavors.
Notable add..... they're really soft but not too soft to the point they're doughy and they don't crumble in your hand either can't say forsure if that's the same case when you warm them up but they are pretty soft yet durable. They also are a bit more on the sweet side but even with that being said 10/10 must try again; their definitely better than crumble cookies .
G
Gladys M
Local Expert • 51 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/21/26
• DoorDash order
I was surprised by the size of the 4-Cookies serving. I certainly don't feel like I got enough cookie for my money (over $13).
I ordered from Lion Cub's Cookies after reading an article naming them 3rd best in the nation as determined by USA Today voters. I disagree with this ranking as I would even call these 3rd best in Columbus. There is nothing special about the cookies and they were dry.
A
Amber S
1 contributions
Loved
• 6/3/25
• DoorDash order
The cookies arrived fresh and still warm! We appreciate the quality, especially for the price. I have never in my life had a favorite chocolate chip cookie until these. I got an assortment, and we loved the variety! The cookies are soft, the fillings and flavors generous, and they are clearly made with love! My husband isnt a big cake person, but he loved these cookies for his birthday. I added some candles I had at home already for the celebration!
D
Daniel P
13 contributions
Loved
• 9/13/25
• DoorDash order
Ok so the cookies-flavor is absolutely delicious. They are not as firm as I thought they'd be. But they are still oven warm. I am going to chill the sugar ones in the freezer & see if they are better. 1000% better than Crumbl. They don't have that weird aftertaste. Large Large Oreo Buttercream was smaller than I expected, but overall I'd give this order a 9.2/10
R
Rachel J
4 contributions
Loved
• 1/19/25
• DoorDash order
I love the variety of flavors and the perfectly sized cookies! Even with changing flavors, cookies are consistently delicious. The staff are friendly and so helpful. The store is always clean!
