The white pizza was phenomenal l! We also loved the lasagna pizza. Would definitely order again!
A
Alicia R
1 contributions
Loved
• 11/9/25
• DoorDash order
We order fairly often, this time we tried the BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA and the MOZZARELLA BREAD! Both were fantastic! The pizza had just enough buffalo to ranch ratio, neither was over powering, which I tend to find a lot of buffalo chicken pizzas to be. And as always, THE RANCH! Thank you for offering a larger size! We literally get one for the meal and one to save for later lol
D
Dawn B
2 contributions
Loved
• 6/4/26
• DoorDash order
Their pizza is always amazing! This time I added a chicken Parmesan sandwich. The chicken was not a frozen patty. It was freshly breaded and absolutely delicious. The only thing I would do differently is ask for more marinara. I like it more saucy, that could just be me. Johnny Tomatoes does not disappoint!
W
William C
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/21/26
• DoorDash order
Not one to complain and I get it's snow bird season on a Friday night but here was my "first time" experience here. So the Door Dash app was saying it would be ready in one hour from when I ordered. No problem at all with that. Again I get it. However, after arriving (I did pickup vs delivery) it took almost another hour to get our food. Every time I questioned it upon arrival they told me "another 20 minutes". As we get the food home there was an overwhelming smell of garlic. The Parmesan Garlic wings and the mozzarella bread were literally covered in minced garlic and I mean covered. Like you couldn't even see the wings in the container. The two pizzas were just ok. Kind of doughy. Don't know if it was their oven or the lack of attention by the employees. Wanted to like this place as they are close but I think I'll stick with Pink Fire Pizza or Asaro's.
C
Corey V
2 contributions
Loved
• 1/9/26
• DoorDash order
Love it. Can tell they actually toss their pies right. Great taste. Would like an option for well done but otherwise amazeballs. Sauce verymild and not acidic for a red sauce. Will be getting again! Kudos to the staff!
