Our Story: Our mission is simple: to provide our valued customers with a taste of authentic, New York-style bagels, right here in Edgewater.
What We Offer: 🥯 Freshly Made Bagels: Each day a wide var…
Wow!! Got the Barn sub with 3 meats and cheese. Very very good!! It was very packed and large! The veggies were the best crunchy fresh! Tomatoes tasted like Jersey tomatoes! Thank you!! I found a great fresh Deli sandwich! We'll be back!
W
William R
12 contributions
Loved
• 9/26/25
• DoorDash order
These guys make an amazing sandwich!! Just look at this photo! Roast Beef w/Swiss on Rye. I tore the bread when I picked it up to take the photo. It was PERFECT!! I can hardly pick it up and I'm not a tiny woman.
D
Danielle A
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/21/25
• DoorDash order
We order from Bagel Barn frequently and it's always been really good! but today I ordered 1/2lb Grape & Walnut Chix Salad,which I've had previously and it was great, but today I can't even eat it. It tastes like a cup.of salt was added. I even tried adding my own mayonnaise to cut the salt but it's still inedible. I called them to let them know and I was surprised after I explained that the girl I spoke to just said "ok" and after a long silence added a forced " sorry" when we were hanging up. Disappointed that I spent about $30 on lunch and they don't really care...
probably find another place for bagels now 😕
D
Dionna L
15 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/27/24
• DoorDash order
The food was ok. You have a lot of food for the price if you receive it all.
They forgot an item, and some of my potatoes were burnt. This was my first time ordering from them. I might try them again.
W
William R
12 contributions
Liked
• 8/19/25
• DoorDash order
Their sandwiches and bagels are great. Today I ordered pastrami pressed assuming/hoping it would resemble grilled pastrami, but just pressed no butter outside so a bit dry. I wish they had a grilled pastrami sandwich, and/or allowed an option in the options, or allowed special instructions.
