I've been a loyal customer since the 1970s when I grew up around the corner from Hicksville. From waiting on line on weekend mornings with my dad to being a delinquent hanging out in their parking lot eating a fresh hot bialy dripping with melted butter to being the after party hotspot in the early morning hours to eventually delivering their coffee to now ordering their devious bagels and lox from close by Massapequa...BAGEL WILL ALWAYS BE THE KING OF BAGELS ON LONG ISLAND, ALWAYS. Second to none!
p.s. sorry for the mostly eaten bagel in the photo, it had been awhile and I couldn't wait
M
Matthew K
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Liked
• 9/19/26
• DoorDash order
this past week I ordered twice from here and both times I had ordered a cheese Cheese Danish. one the first time and 2 the second as one was for someone else. they were not the same as the first time ordered. the pastry itself wasnt the problem but it had like a mini smear at just the center of the Danish for both of them. I dont like criticizing but I wont lie either.
the 3 bagels were avg. As a piece of onion that found its way over to the sesame bagel and on the last bite which irked me. im sure everybody know what i mean regardless of bagel store (though i will say they let that happen a lot fewer than other strores do which is notable as it does ruin a meal if not careful.
the amt of crm chs was a little on the light side especially for that crazy pric but was fresh and tasty.
more crm chs or lower price.(rather say and over or)
would order again but when I have money to blow. 3 bagels and 2 near empty chs danish w/ a nes quick and tip at $43.18. i am a dashpass user
M
Matthew K
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Loved
• 6/12/26
• DoorDash order
better but still expensive. they used a bit more cream cheese this time.
I get the bagel lightly toasted and if you've ever had a warm bagel with cream cheese you'd know it starts to liquify. almost like what happens after using whipped cream and letting it sit out for a little while. brownie isnt bad. its fudge but not the brownie itself but the fudge Danish thats layered on top which almost always topped with a generous sprinkle of m&m's. the brownie itself isnt bad but definately not of the best quality as its a little dried/stale, not very just a little. its still better than a lot of other ones out there. oh its fairly thin as well but dont get the wrong idea. its dense and very very filling and take that from someone who always has room for dessert.
M
Matthew K
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Loved
• 5/13/26
• DoorDash order
expensive.
the light toasted sesame flagel had some burn spots on some parts of the edges.
it would be nice if you can ask for some thing without calling like if you want a specific type of cheese or condiments. I did call and asked for the swiss and the Swiss cheese tasted off.
cookie was a bit on the small side for 5 dollars it did taste good not gourmet good but good.
oh and keep in mind its much more after taxes tip and fees.other than that it was good.
M
Matthew K
Emerging Expert • 35 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/24/26
• DoorDash order
I ordered a sesame flagel anda poppy flagel.(theyre 75 cents more ea.) i ended up receiving a poppy bagel and a whole wheat sesame flagel.
As usual inconsistent with the Cream Cheese (not enough) its bad considering im paying almost $10 for a freakin bagel with cream cheese and there skimpy with it. I didnt like the taste of the whole wheat either which made it even more of a dissapointment and its not like it was able to be countered with the cc cause there was barely any on it. oh they want me to mention the nesquik...
oh the flagel had some burnt edges like 1 spot 6cm (I didnt get it toasted and it wasnt so i guess it was a bad flagel.
im usually happy with the food even though its expensive so i should be happy but I was truly not happy and disappointed this time.
I dont go by menu price i go by the amt paid and divide by items purchased and add that yo ea. items menu price to get the cost $3-4 tip.
+cc is always fresh however and the poppy bagel was good
