

Jay Rays Sandwiches
4.9(200+)•
DashPass•
Deli•
Store Info
DashPass
4.9(200+)•
Deli
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
1. Italian Beef
$11.50
•100% (15)
#1 Most liked
6. Chopped Jay Ray
$10.00
10. Meatball
$11.50
3. De Niro
$11.00
•100% (12)
#2 Most liked
21. Classic Italian
$9.50
9. Big Chungus
$16.00
Reviews200+ ratings • 10+ public reviews
4.9
of 5 stars
G
Gregory F
1 contributionsLoved
• 3/3/26Jay Ray's Never Disappoints!
Absolutely loved the Goodfella with heated meat and cheese.
Can't say a bad word about any sandwich I have ever eaten from this true diamond in the rough.
You can have your Jimmy johns, subway, jersey mikes.
I will have Jay Ray's, save money and enjoy better taste and quality.
T
Tiffany B
Local Expert • 28 contributionsLoved
• 2/18/26So fresh, great portions, always happy to order again and again. Milwaukee Melt never disappoints with delivering spicy heat. If you're looking for something reminiscent of an Italian, the Ollie is a delicious spin on it. The only opportunity for improvement is replacing the use of styrofoam containers.
T
Tiffany B
Local Expert • 28 contributionsLoved
• 10/30/25Great food with fresh ingredients! The 8. Milwaukee Melt delivers a respectable amount of spicy heat balanced with the other ingredients. The 9. Big Chungus is aptly named as the bread fought a hard battle to contain all the ingredients. So happy this is available via Door Dash. Will be trying more off the menu in the future!
K
K H
4 contributionsLoved
• 10/25/25The O.G. is a bussin banger!! Jay Rays does it right with loading this piece of art up with the freshest quality ingredients. This bad boy is HUGE! I'm so excited they are finally on DD!!! Definitely going to be ordering in the delivery rotation future.
B
Brooke Phillips F
13 contributionsLoved
• 4/15/26I rarely leave reviews because I feel like most places aren't consistent. Bomb once, horrible the next time. But Jay Rays is AMAZING every single time. Sammy's can be lil dicey when ordering delivery cuz they get soggy fast- but our Sammy's were fresh & delicious & high quality ingredients (I did order all our Sammy's with dressing in the side tho). And that raspberry mustard?! Yuuuummmyyy. Best sandwich shop around.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Featured Items
Sides N' Stuff
Specialty Sandwiches
Add extra meat or extra cheese for an additional charge. Make it a meal! Add a drink and chips for an additional charge.
Signature Sandwiches
Add extra meat or extra cheese for an additional charge. Make it a meal! Add a drink and chips for an additional charge.
Fresh Favorites
Add extra meat or extra cheese for an additional charge. Make it a meal! Add a drink and chips for an additional charge.