Absolutely DELICIOUS!! Subs are incredible because they use the garlic bread! YUUUUMMMM
G
Garnet Renee M
Emerging Expert • 52 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/4/25
• DoorDash order
The order was $61.07 and both the Build Your Own Pizza and Build Your Own Calzone were burnt and the cheese was rubbery. This food was too overcooked to eat. Huge disappointment. Pizza Cottage has gone downhill. It used to be good. Not worth all that money.
B
Bob A
11 contributions
Loved
• 4/30/26
• DoorDash order
Great as ALWAYS!!! From Chicago for thin pizza one of the best two in Columbus. Rubinos in Bexleg and Pizza Cottage
C
Crystal R
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/30/25
• DoorDash order
The quality has taken a huge nose dive. Used to really love their food. Ordered a PLT sub with no tomatoes tonight along with a pizza. Opened the sub and there were tomatoes. But that's not the worst part. There was less than 20 pepperonis on the entire sub!! They use the little dime sized pepperonis, so when that's the main protein and you're paying over $13 dollars, I expect more. It was like eating a big crusty bun with mayo and lettuce and a sprinkle of pepperoni. Didn't used to be like this, but consistently getting worse with every order. Beyond disappointing and they are losing a long time, loyal customer.
K
Krista H
Emerging Expert • 28 contributions
Loved
• 4/2/25
• DoorDash order
I haven't had Pizza Cottage since I lived out in Millersport 30 years ago, and it is as awesome now as it was then! Build Your Own Pizza was spot on! I got thin crust, husband got thick, both were so good!
