Times Square Pizza & Bagels
4.7(500+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info
DashPass
4.7(500+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
9:00 am - 7:40 pmFeatured Items
$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time
Featured Items
NY Pepperoni - 18" XXL
$26.95
•100% (22)
#1 Most liked
NY Original Cheese - 18" XXL
$23.95
•93% (15)
#3 Most liked
NY Pepperoni - 12" Medium
$20.95
•100% (9)
NY White Pie - 18" XXL
$33.95
Wings (10)
$16.95
•85% (7)
NY Margherita - 12" Medium
$23.95
•100% (8)
Reviews500+ ratings • 30+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
J
Jim T
1 contributionsLoved
• 2/12/23There is no close second to this pizza. Cooked in the correct ovens. Same as all pizzerias used in NY and NJ. Thin, crisp but chewy crust. Meant to be folded. Great sauce and cheese. All the normal topping to choose from.
Again, there is other decent pizza in town but if you want NY/NJ pizzeria pizza. This is the only place in Temecula or Murietta.
H
Heather M
6 contributionsLoved
• 5/8/26Great quality of food EVERYtime! My son and I love the pizza bites. There's just enough to fill him and I. The bagel sandwiches are full of flavor too! This place is a frequent repeat for my family. We love it.
M
Mallary T
4 contributionsLoved
• 7/2/25Our go-to pizza place. The medium seems to have a teeny bit more dough in the crust which I like. The Chef's Dipping sauce is a delicious dipping sauce for the pizza. It tastes a lot like a slightly spicy Caesar dressing. The cheese sticks when ordered without garlic are a puffy thick circle of pizza dough covered in melty cheese. Super good... for eight year olds that hate foods that taste like things other than cheese. The marinara that comes with the cheese sticks tastes like a can. It comes cold which makes me feel good from a food safety perspective but tastes like a can so we skip it. Always hot, very consistent, they never spell my name right. We eat here every week.
A
Ariana L
Local Expert • 129 contributionsDidn't like
• 11/6/25First time trying them out and it was okay but nothing special or worth making me come back due to cravings. The bagel was dense and didn't have that great bagel flavor. The Turkey Club Sandwich ingredients didn't taste fresh. Poor quality turkey. Not terrible but not something I would ever come back for-- better bagel sandwiches elsewhere. The pizza was fine but like the most basic pizza you've ever tasted. I've had more flavorful frozen pizzas. Portion size was decent but the price for these two items came out to $50 with all the other fees and what not which doesn't equal the quality in this case. Overall not bad food, nothing was gross, just not worth coming back or memorable.
M
Mena M
3 contributionsLoved
• 4/18/24It's so difficult to find a good gluten free pizza that tastes good and feels safe. I've ordered this several times and always felt good, it's just gotten better overtime as well less greasy, cooked perfectly, cute details like the paper sheet to keep things clean, love feeling like I can order out and be normal, tastes like real pizza
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store
Customize Your Own Pizza - New York Style Pizza
New York Calzones
Served with marinara sauce.