Tomato Pie Pizza Joint brings real New York-style pizza to the West Coast with crispy-yet-chewy crusts and bold, nostalgic flavor. But we’re more than just pizza — our menu features handcrafted pastas…
The gluten free pizza is pretty awesome. The crust is thin and the cheese seems sparse, so I didn't know if I'd like the pizza. It's really good. Ask for extra cheese if you prefer your pizza to be covered in it. I told them, "The more sauce the better." So, they may have put more on mine than normal. I loved it.
T
Tiffany G
8 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/11/24
• DoorDash order
The ziti was a monumental disappointment. It tasted as though something was spoiled or "off." It smelled bad too. I ended up throwing it out. What a waste of money. I would not recommend this. The meatballs were small and seemed as though they were frozen and reheated. They weren't tasty either. Two, small meatballs came in a huge container with a bit of sauce and arrived cold.
S
Sophie L
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/23/24
• DoorDash order
Im confused by the high rating of this place, my entire order was poor. I ordered the BBQ chicken and it arrived with approx 5 cubes of chicken on it, hidden under the cheese. If I wanted a cheese and red onion pizza i would have ordered that. The pizza was also lukewarm as it's not delivered in a pizza box bag.
The "newyork cheesecake" was an absolute joke. $6 for a slice the size of the palm of my hand.... pictures attached. And sadly the taste did not compensate for the tiny size.
Really disappointed and will not be ordering again.
J
Joan K
18 contributions
Loved
• 12/12/22
• DoorDash order
The meatballs are always tender and delicious, I'm addicted. The croutons & ranch dressing are 100% of why I get the Caesar salad, the lettuce is great but the croutons & dressing are amazing.
R
Rachel P
Local Expert • 48 contributions
Loved
• 7/23/23
• DoorDash order
This Bronx expat is impressed. Since I moved to LA, it's harder to find pizza like I'm used to back east. It's definitely more expensive out here too. But this place is a gem that makes pizza just like you're back on either side of the Hudson. Perfect treat for New Yorkers and New Jerseyans feeling homesick!
