The food was excellent. I ordered two large trays, and I must say, the reviewers seem to have missed the mark. The pizzas are generously sized and satisfying. The ingredients are well-layered and evenly distributed. The ricotta had a delightful lemon-infused flavor, which is quite unique for a pizza. I absolutely loved it. My only suggestion would be to substitute ham with anchovies on the pineapple pizza. You can thank me later. For a party of two, I highly recommend two large trays. They’re thick, perfect for sharing, and you’ll still be pleased the next day.
M
Marcus L
Emerging Expert • 34 contributions
Liked
• 10/31/25
• DoorDash order
It took forever to arrive And it was a little small for the price point. But it was still warm. Honestly, might be my new "GO TO" pizza spot. Delicious sauce. Great crust Spicy pepperoni cups and honey just a GREAT PIZZA. REALLY good.
T
Tyler M
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 11/1/25
• DoorDash order
Ambrosia. Great pomodoro. The Pepperoni is delectible. The hot honey is not overbearing in any way and it really balances the flavors. It slaps like a gorgeous South Shore Bar pizza in the crust with all that gorgeous crisp browning that goes South good dough in a blackened, seasoned pan. The pomodoro helps this taste like an italian casserole dish: very homey. Can't recommend them enough, as all of my orders from Johnny Pomodoro have been perfect and delivered fast.
MyCrispy Pepperoni Cup review.
T
Tyler M
Emerging Expert • 12 contributions
Loved
• 8/14/25
• DoorDash order
I grew up on South Shore Bar Pizza, and this is my first Detroit-style Pizza (at least that's what I think it is? pardon my ignorance if so.
NO MATTER! lol the Crispy Pepperoni Cup is just straight up baller: if you have cravings for the bar/pan/sheet pizza browned in a well-seasoned & blackened pan kind of vibes, Johnny Pomodoro slaps so hard. The cheese is phenomenal, everything is fresh, delivers really well, and they don't put "pomodoro" in their name for nothing: it's topped with a bright tomato sauce that balances all the flavors. Pepperonis? Fuhgedaboutit. It's got the smallest sweet flavors of tomato fruit & a kiss of honey. No complaints ever, multiple orders. I'll never be a skinny boy.
B
Brianna H
Emerging Expert • 20 contributions
Loved
• 8/27/25
• DoorDash order
Their food is very good. The first bite, you will taste the high-quality. From the ingredients to the seasoning everything was wonderful. Perfectly packaged as well.
They also give you a nice portion for what you paid for . I highly recommend and I would order from here again.
