Nelly's Italian Cafe
4.8(4k+)•
Pizzeria•
Store Info•
Closed
Order now, get it later
4.8(4k+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Spring Hills Best Pizza! Authentic NY Style Pizza!
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
Opens Aug 11
Order for later
Featured Items
Create a Pizza Extra Large
$22.58
•93% (16)
Create a Pizza Large
$20.48
•80% (21)
#2 Most liked
Large Supreme
$30.44
XL Double Crust Meatlover
$69.29
Large Bianca
$25.20
XL Veggie
$30.44
Reviews4k+ ratings • 90+ public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
C
Cassandra C
1 contributionsLoved
• 12/14/22My kids loved the pepperoni pizza, my husband got lasagna and said it was better than Olive Garden which he loves, and I ordered the Chicken Parm Roll and it was so huge I'll probably take leftovers to work tomorrow. All in all the food was better than i expected
R
Ryan K
Emerging Expert • 11 contributionsLoved
• 2/16/23Pizza arrived hot, delicious and perfect. The cannolis are to die for. Absolutely love Nelly's NY style pizza and I hate to move and leave them behind. Worth every penny. Our family will definitely be visiting and getting Nelly's on each visit!
J
Jason F
Emerging Expert • 8 contributionsLoved
• 7/10/24The pizzas were delicious! Each had a sweet and savory sauce topped with the freshest ingredients. The pepperoni and sausage had the perfect amount of bite to them. The crust is soft like a bread stick with a nice crunch.
S
Samantha F
Emerging Expert • 15 contributionsLoved
• 8/29/25Phenomenal every time! My favorite is the pepperoni Stromboli with a fresh slice of their amazing turtle cheesecake.
S
Serenity M
6 contributionsDidn't like
• 7/19/26The only reason I ordered from Nelly's tonight was for the garlic knots. I even thought about ordering only the garlic knots, b/c they have been so phenomenal in the past.
There were 6 slices of garlic bread here, but a friend and I tried it. This is not a viable substitution for your amazing garlic knots. :(
The pizza is tasty, but the garlic bread is a pretty big disappointment when I was expecting y'all's best garlic knots ever. :(
In the future, please let your customers know when you'll be offering this "substitution."
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store