https://a816-health.nyc.gov/ABCEatsRestaurants/#!/Search
Magnolia is the bakery that put cupcakes on the map, but truth be told, this beloved bake shop is worth every bit of hype it’s ever received.…
This is the best Magnolia I've had! And I've tried many in the city ...they know we like more cookies and less bananas and that's what they give us!
K
Kaitlin D
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 11/17/25
• Orden de DoorDash
The red velvet cake was drier than I expected, and the frosting wasn't cream cheese but plain vanilla! Who heard of that with red velvet. Portion size was worth the money but the taste was not -- would not order again.
S
Sabrina T
3 contributions
Didn't like
• 12/31/25
• Orden de DoorDash
Only 3 little pieces of bananas, was too overpowering and sweet doesn't taste like the other 2 I bought couple days ago. Too many wafers and they were hard as hell. Just trifling had to throw it away wasn't appealing to sight nor taste.
P
Parish D
Emerging Expert • 17 contributions
Loved
• 9/4/26
• Orden de DoorDash
Classic Banana Pudding is a city staple and so long as Magnolia is open I will go there for pudding when I'm out in the city.
A
Anthony C
42 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/9/25
• Orden de DoorDash
My cake slices were NOT MOIST. Cake slices arrived cold because the cakes have been refrigerated. . Who knows for how long??? The only thing I enjoyed was the banana pudding. Unfortunately, had very little banana sliced bits in the 4 oz cup.
One thing they need to improve is the amount of frosting in their servings. . Goodness, ... soooooo much frosting and mediocre size of actual bread cake.
