Josie’s Pizza Hilltop History
Placid Catalfina immigrated to the US on December 22, 1920 from Sicily, Italy at the young age of 13 years, along with his family. He sailed into New York Harbor on the…
Ordered the Gut Buster (meat lovers) well done, Italian sub , and Onion Rings. We'll definitely be ordering from Josie's again, the pizza was loaded and tasty, onion rings crispy, and sub was on point. Keep up the amazing quality!!!🙌🏼
R
Robert W
Local Expert • 87 contributions
Loved
• 3/21/26
• DoorDash order
One Item Pizza (Small 10") tastes amazing! I always get extra sauce because their sauce is delicious. You get plenty f food for your money too. Pizza arrives freshly baked to perfection, they use plenty of toppings and lots of cheese. Best pizza in town!
A
Alexa S
25 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/19/26
• DoorDash order
The One Item Pizza (Small 10") was just okay. The sauce was eh, and cheese was different.
The Fried Mushrooms (12) however, were very good. I was given a salad packet of ranch instead of a little container of ranch though. Just so people are aware of the type of ranch you get with the mushrooms.
R
Robert W
Local Expert • 87 contributions
Loved
• 6/4/25
• DoorDash order
Everything I've ordered is spot on, pizzas, subs, fries, pasta dinners. Today Igot a chef salad and it was awesome. The salad was huge, the veggies were crisp and cool, came with plenty of dressing and the additional grilled chicken came packaged in its own container so it didn't wilt the salad. This restaurant is a gem, the prices are more than reasonable and the food is great. My favorite Italian/Pizza place!
M
Mark D
Emerging Expert • 25 contributions
Loved
• 9/4/23
• DoorDash review
The best spaghetti dinner I've ever had from a pizza place. Meatballs and sauce had great flavor and the quantity was amazing. The Italian sub and old fashioned pepperoni pizza was excellent also . I also ordered the garlic bread with cheese that was great and toasted perfectly! Moves to the top of my preference for pizza!
