Whenever we open DD we check to see if this place is open, IT IS THAT GOOD. Mystery Box never misses! Chocolate Chip Cookie are a must try!
S
Sherryann F
Local Expert • 48 contributions
Loved
• 2/21/25
• DoorDash order
They have just officially became my new place for baked goods. I am so impressed with the Mystery Box . it is packed full with various goodies. well worth the money. but the kicker is the thank you note. double heart shaped shortbread cookies with frosting. I'm telling everyone about Miss May Designs Bake Shop
J
Jen C
Emerging Expert • 15 contributions
Loved
• 4/25/25
• DoorDash order
When they were out of the Lemon Drop Cookie that I ordered, not only did they refund me, they sent me a free piece of iced lemon cake! Their Chocolate Chip Cookies are better than my grandma's (don't tell her) and the customer service is an A+. Wish they were open more often!
L
Lisa R
Local Expert • 121 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/28/25
• DoorDash order
Chocolate Fudge Brownie was very good! Basic Cupcake Vanilla was just okay. Jumbo Wedding Cake Raspberry Cupcake was not jumbo in size and was not filled with radp , but instead topped with it. Yummy but very messy My order was acco by a thank you cookie, which was very nice.
E
Erica C
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/16/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered the Mystery Box and it looked so good! There was a cupcake, a macaron, a cake pop, a delicious-looking fat sugar cookie, and a big piece of apple cake. I handed my son the sugar cookie and after he took a big bite, he teared up and asked me if I hate him. The sugar crystals all over the cookie were actually salt! So much salt. Some of the salt fell into the apple cake which wasn't so bad, but the cookie itself was aggressively salty. Was this an unfortunate mistake? Do you actually sell a salt cookie? I hope not
