True Wood Fire Neapolitan Pizza!
Starting out as a Covid pop-up, we grew and grew until we were able to open up our Brick-and-Mortar location in Nutley NJ. Full Story on our website!
The best kind of pizza where the crust is as delicious as the toppings. Plus the ricotta doubled as both a topping AND a dip.
S
Shweta S
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 2/9/25
• DoorDash order
Pizza not worth at all
Don't waste your money here
There was hardly any basil tomato or cheese
It was just crust dough
K
Kayla P
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/22/26
• DoorDash review
I’m honestly really disappointed because I had a completely different experience ordering from Emilio’s Wood Fire Pizza this time compared to my first order on May 9th. The first margherita pizza I ordered was delicious and looked exactly like the photos they advertise online — fluffy wood-fired crust, fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, and overall high quality. That positive experience is the reason I ordered again.
Tonight, however, I opened the box and received what looked more like a thin-crust cheese pizza with tiny pieces of what appeared to be spinach scattered on top instead of fresh basil. The crust was thin and flat, not the thick, airy wood-fired dough that is advertised on their website and delivery platforms. The fresh mozzarella was also replaced with grated cheese, which completely changed the pizza.
When I called the restaurant, I was told they do “Tavern Thursdays,” where the margherita pizza is made differently — thin crust, grated cheese, and basil sprinkled on instead of the traditional version. My issue is not necessarily that they offer a different style on Thursdays — it’s that this was NOT clearly advertised anywhere on the website or ordering platform where I placed my order. I was instead told that the information is posted on Instagram.
That is unacceptable. Customers should not have to check a restaurant’s social media to find out that the item they’re ordering is completely different from what is being advertised on the actual ordering platform. If the pizza is going to be fundamentally changed one day a week, that should be clearly stated on the website, menu, and delivery apps before checkout. Otherwise, it feels misleading and false advertising.
The pizza I received looked nothing like the photos used to advertise the margherita pizza, and not at all like the one I previously received. Really disappointing experience, especially after such a great first order.
M
Mateus P
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/8/26
• DoorDash order
It's for the best pizza I ever had
Real but real Italian pizza
R
Romeo P
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/8/25
• DoorDash order
Margherita is a huge let-down. Compared to the photos, you get like 2 Leaves of Basil. Might as well call it a Cheese Pizza instead.
