Located on the corner of Baxter Avenue and East Broadway in the heart of the Highlands Neighborhood of Louisville, Goodfellas Baxter is our most recent addition to the pizzeria family.
Stop by for a …
Al Pacino - D2D This delicious!!! bread is very soft, the sauce with the meatballs and the melted cheese creates a fabulous combination are too delicious!!!
Calzone - D2D Not to mention the Calzone, it is too rich, the dough very well cooked and depending on the ingredients you choose you create a great feeling on your palate, 100% recommended!!
M
Mike H
Local Expert • 20 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/12/25
• DoorDash order
Got the 16 in Don and the Goodfella. Crust was good-thin and very chewy. Toppings were moderate-not much cheese or sauce . Pies were of little substance and did not weigh much. $88 for two chewy light weight pies including tip, that were adequate to fair, not great . And not very filling. Overall, poor value for money. There are better cheaper options. Never again!
E
Emily R
4 contributions
Loved
• 3/22/25
• DoorDash order
I wish I could do a 10/10 score because this place deserves it! We ordered the 12" Pie - D2D with "The Vinny" as our base and added Italian sausage, bacon, sun dried tomatoes, roasted red peppers, and spinach. The ingredients tasted so fresh and clean, the crust was moist yet still crunchy, and it was just an all around refreshing meal. I seriously recommend this place to anyone who isn't a huge pizza fan, this will change your life.
J
Jaicee R
1 contributions
Loved
• 2/21/25
• DoorDash review
I always have the best pizza from goodfellas! They've never disappointed me, and the consistency is always top tier ! My favorite has to be their Margherita pizza with the house made ranch!!! If you're looking for something quick, easy and delicious order here!!
C
Camryn H
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/27/25
• DoorDash order
When my Calzone - D2D arrived, it barely had any crust. The ricotta was sitting on the paper-- it was like they had ran out of crust and just made it anyways. I basically was served a $15 pile of toppings.
