BOGO Margherita Pie was a no-brainer. Fiotella's pizzas are top notch. The crust is baked perfectly and always delightfully crisp. Nonna's Meatballs are above average, we love dipping crust in the sauce.
L
Liza H
Local Expert • 31 contributions
Liked
• 2/3/26
• DoorDash order
Rigatoncini Al Bolognese Classico was OUTSTANDING and AMAZING in every way
10 out of 10.
Want a refund on the olive oil cake. Stale small round and gross. Nothing like photo. Polenta Olive Oil Cake is terrible dry :-(
L
Lauren
4 contributions
Didn't like
• 1/25/25
• DoorDash order
This restaurant is having serious quality control issues. This is the second time in a row they have sent us an order that was more incorrect than correct. This time they sent us the wrong pizza, and the pizza we got was severely undercooked, and a serving size of the farro salad that had to be a mistake because it was literally 3 bites worth of food.
L
Lane B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/19/25
• DoorDash order
Poorly made with cheese barely covering half of the pizza. Also forgot to cut it. Definitely not what I would expect given the premium price. Almost no cheese on the kids pizza either
L
Larry R
Local Expert • 22 contributions
Loved
• 1/27/25
• DoorDash order
The Good Neighbor Pie is the absolute BOMB. Incredible sauce and flavorful taste on this pizza. The regular Margherita Pie pales in comparison!! The Good Neighbor is one of the best pies in the city, hands down!
