The Commodore
4.7(3k+)•
DashPass•
American•
Store Info
DashPass
Open now
4.7(3k+)•
$$•American
https://a816-health.nyc.gov/ABCEatsRestaurants/#!/Search
Full Menu
4:00 pm - 12:45 amFeatured Items
1 min
ready for pickup
Featured Items
Hot Breast Sandwich
$22.00
•88% (53)
#1 Most liked
Fried Chicken Plate
$28.00
•89% (49)
#2 Most liked
Cadillac Nachos
$22.00
•88% (35)
#3 Most liked
Mexican Chicken Soup
$17.00
Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich
$21.00
Brisket Dip Sandwich
$21.00
Reviews3k+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
J
Jacquelyn R
Emerging Expert • 15 contributionsLoved
• 10/16/24Medium chicken sandwich is huge and delicious. It does have a little mayo on it (not mentioned in the description but I was happy it was there). Chicken is cooked right and was still crispy upon delivery.
The fries are also good, but a little dry.
T
Terence a
Emerging Expert • 6 contributionsDidn't like
• 10/4/26AVOID the dessert.
Thimble-size is describing the portion graciously .
Stick to the terrific entrées!!
While I love the food at the Commodore and my chicken sandwich and biscuits with honey butter did not disappoint, there was one reason alone that compelled me to order from The Commodore last night, and unfortunately, they let me down with enormously.
Ever have a craving for something and you've just got to have it? You're willing to scour the city far 'n wide? That was me last night. Although I knew that I didn't have to go far because I knew precisely where to satisfy this particular craving. I couldn't get Key Lime Pie pie out of my mind, I was craving it beyond all measure & nothing else would do. So, the mini keylime pie was the first thing that I placed in my cart. Although I've enjoyed it many times, solely on premises, I didn't give it even a passing thought that delivery would be any different.
However,the keylime pie fell far short of the mark. Ordinarily I'd effusively rave that their pastry chef's confection was ne plus ultra.
The major fail last night was due to the fact that they surreptitiously performed sleight-of-hand and had the audacity to deliver a cup that was virtually devoid of any food (and I would've paid any price!)
Perhaps they're trying yet another new concept:
"Kitchen Gaslighting"?
Charge the customer the usual nine dollars for the dessert, deliver a cup that is virtually empty, and hope that the customer is duped into silence, taking a chapter from the recently renamed:
"emperor's-new-clothes-keylime-pie",
a GL-P version that satisfies diabetics and Weight Watchers aficionados alike (zero points!)
If they had sold out of the dish, no problem, simply strike it from the bill and don't deliver a cup that's basically empty. However, they sent me what could only be described as not-quite-an-actual-bite to qualify as an amuse-bouche.
The sole reason that I was able to confirm that they did indeed send the scrumptious ghost-bouche was because I scraped along the lining of the very bottom of the cup with the very tippy top of my spoon - yep, scrape, scrape, scrape. There was no depth whatsoever lining the bottom of the cup, so I was unable to collect the equivalent of an actual spoonful of the custard.
So....yum?
Yep.
but to quote Theodor Seuss Geisel:
"...leaving [a crumb] much too small
for the other Whos' mouses!"
This customer has long sidled up to the bar at the Commodore, enjoying the entire menu since day one, after having been a pioneer explorer at his original concept when biscuits, chicken and pie was foreign indeed,
Never having had to embark on a scavenger hunt in order to reveal a missing mini keylime pie when dining on premises, I feel hoodwinked,
Trading on their (former?) stellar reputation?
Not a great look.
D
Dana C
1 contributionsLoved
• 5/26/24The quality of the food is impeccable! One area for improvement would be on the level of spice of the items. The Wedge Salad was fresh and delicious, however, to complement the savory MEDIUM BREAST SANDWICH and French Fries, i would have asked for it to have zero spice (couldn't figure out where the spice came from). You are not able to add specific requests unless you call the restaurant which sort of eliminates the convenience of using an app. Either way, the level of food for delivery is top notch.
Z
Zhane W
Emerging Expert • 12 contributionsDidn't like
• 12/19/25Mayo was watery , sandwich smaller than usual. Not worth 35.55 to be honest. Don't know if I'm ordering for a while...
Z
Zhane W
Emerging Expert • 12 contributionsDidn't like
• 5/29/25The chicken is usually moist and seasoned and the bread is not usually over-toasted. My chicken was blank and dry and the bread was dark brown
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store