Tonys Pizza
4.7(200+)•
DashPass•
Pizzeria•
Store Info•
DashPass
Closed
Order now, get it later
4.7(200+)•
$$•Pizzeria
Full Menu
2:00 pm - 10:55 pmFeatured Items
Opens 2:00 PM
Order for later
Featured Items
Large Square Pizza (12 Slices)
$20.34
•100% (12)
#2 Most liked
Large Round Pizza (8 Slices)
$19.14
•95% (22)
#1 Most liked
Medium Round Pizza (6 Slices)
$11.94
•100% (8)
#3 Most liked
Old Forge Classic
$21.54
•100% (8)
Steak and Cheese
$26.34
Half Tray Square
$10.74
•100% (8)
Reviews200+ ratings • 20+ public reviews
4.7
of 5 stars
S
Sean T
1 contributionsLoved
• 6 days agoGreat pizza, great personalities, always consistent. I've been eating their pizza or 10+ years and it's always on point.
I recommend the square (Large Square Pizza (12 Slices))9 the square with extra sauce on top. i also do sausage and extra cheese.
B
Brian T
6 contributionsLoved
• 4/16/26I should have left this review a long time ago. Door dash delivers long distance from Olyphant to Taylor which I really appreciate. The Old Forge Red is so freaking awesome. Crispy crust. That amazing sauce and I usually get with Sausage and Mushroom. It is so proportionally balanced. Just right with the toppings. Not overwhelming. This pizza is better than what I can get in Old Forge. No disrespect intended. Thank you Sauce Doctor. I really appreciate it.
K
Karen N
Emerging Expert • 9 contributionsLoved
• 7/31/25The Work<<taggedItemId=24087547888>>s
Large Round Pizza (8 Slices)<</taggedItemId>>
The Large Round Pizza (8 Slices) was delicious as always. Extra sauce makes the Pizza. Ordered the The Works for the first time. It was heavy as a kitchen sink and really good.
D
D K
149 contributionsLoved
• 11/29/25Best pizza I've had in years. The cheese and sauce are beyond delicious! Definitely will order weekly. So glad it's on door dash.
F
Frank K
1 contributionsDidn't like
• 2/8/26Old Forge style had very little cheese. Didn't even reach the end of crust. Potato Crust Personal Pizza was doughy. Required oven and was overly sweet (sauce). $48 for the order including tip. Definitely not worth it. Very disappointed.
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store