The Bagel Shop (Cape May)
4.8(200+)ā¢
DashPassā¢
Bakeryā¢
Store Infoā¢
DashPass
Closed
Order now, get it later
4.8(200+)ā¢
$$ā¢Bakery
Full Menu
closedFeatured Items
Opens Oct 22
Order for later
Featured Items
Egg & Cheese
$13.80
ā¢100% (18)
#1 Most liked
Smoked Nova Special
$16.80
CHICKEN, EGG, OR TUNA SALAD DELUXE
$19.20
Bagel with Flavored Cream Cheese
$7.20
ā¢100% (7)
Bagel with Whitefish
$15.60
Club Sandwich
$14.40
Reviews200+ ratings ā¢ 9 public reviews
4.8
of 5 stars
V
Virginia G
1 contributionsLoved
ā¢ 5/25/26I just finished the Rosemary Black Pepper bagel and it was amazing. The balance of the herb and pepper was perfect. This would also be fabulous dipped in soup.
K
Katelynn M
2 contributionsDidn't like
ā¢ 9/6/26This bagel was almost 14 dollars and it only came with ONE slice of Taylor ham. I have never once been to a bagel place that has only given one slice of Taylor ham. This is not okay
R
Rita D
12 contributionsDidn't like
ā¢ 9/11/26Forgot the meat on one sandwich. The other sandwich was very skimpy and bialy was mediocre. Definitely overpriced for what you get
A
Amanda K
1 contributionsDidn't like
ā¢ 12/7/25Ordered Smoked Nova Special and Salt Bagel with Cream Cheese. Smoked Nova sounds great but I have no idea as bagel came with nothing but cream cheese. Salt Bagel is actually a pretzel bagel, so since it has salt on it they consider it a salt bagel even though it resembles a pretzel. Spent $34 dollars on specialty items for items we could have gotten at Wawa.
B
bionoce .
12 contributionsDidn't like
ā¢ 10/2/26That "Wildwood sausage" needs to stay in Wildwood. Bad. I had to take it off. Their bagels and eggs are always on point. Bring back whatever sausage you guys used before!!!
Most Ordered
The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store