Welcome to 57 Ninety Restaurant — Depew’s Hidden Gem for Homemade Italian Comfort Food!Our menu is packed with homemade favorites — from hand-tossed pizzas and classic pasta dishes to hearty entrées a…
The Crab Cakes are amazing, as well as the Fried Mozzarella (huge portion), fresh Half Loaf Italian Bread & Butter, and Stuffed Mushrooms. The The 57ninety was very good, tender meat was wonderfully seasoned and the focaccia was perfect. Will absolutely order again. The house sauce is very good. First order to sample, and looking forward to their pasta dishes.
A
Alexa B
4 contributions
Loved
• 11/24/25
• DoorDash order
Enjoyed our Eggplant Parm and Chicken Parm! Portion was sizable and the sauce was a little on the sweeter side. And the Half Loaf Italian Bread & Butter was very fresh. Enjoyed trying this place for the first time!
E
Elizabeth B
3 contributions
Loved
• 2/5/26
• DoorDash order
Stuffed Shells were delicious, so cheesy! the Joey Joey Roll was HUGE!! Definitely will be ordering from here again.
D
Danielle S
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Loved
• 1/10/26
• DoorDash order
The Bear was absolutely amazing! The Fried Mozzarella was the largest I have seen! I am
saving the Half Loaf Italian Bread & Butter for tomorrow morning's breakfast. Can't wait!
K
Kathleen K
6 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/19/26
• DoorDash review
The stuffed shells we had were good, but they didn't include the dipping oils we ordered and paid for. This is the second time they didn't include everything with our order. Next time, I'd only eat in to make sure we got everything we ordered.
