The entire menu is amazing. I've been eating at Mario's for years and it's without a doubt the best pizza spot in town.
Normally I just order by the slice, but the Stromboli and subs are solid too. Really everything on the menu is 10/10.
Oh the garlic knots. Always get the garlic knots. The price on those is a steal.
S
Shawn E
2 contributions
Liked
• 10/19/26
• DoorDash review
When they say "generous slice" they mean it. I ordered two slices because of a buy one get one free deal and I basically came away with half a pizza for like $6. It was delicious and very fresh, not like it had been sitting under lights all day. The toasted ravioli was slightly drier/could have used more filling but it was still good. The cannolis are made with a buttercream mixture rather than ricotta so they are very sweet- just an FYI depending on your preference. The only thing I would not order again was the garlic knots. They were a little hard and very bland. The pizza was for sure the star here, very delicious.
K
Kathy L
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/20/25
• DoorDash order
15 inch NY Pizza, lots of toppings, crust chewy. We are in a hotel room, name of which was on the order, and No plates or napkins! Not happy about that. common sense? Wish our Door Dash driver would have picked those up with the delivery.
B
Ben J
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/12/23
• DoorDash order
Caesar salad was delicious with fresh ingredients. Stromboli was large, piping hot, and loaded with toppings. Marinara served with Stromboli was disappointing. Had the texture of warm ketchup with no trace of herbs or seasoning usually associated with a good marinara. Overall Caesar and Stromboli were great. Marinara served with the Stromboli sucked!
S
Shannon M
2 contributions
Loved
• 12/5/22
• DoorDash order
The Stromboli is large and the ingredients were fresh. The garlic knots are smothered in butter and delicious. The cannoli is one the best I've ever had!
