Brooklyn Boys is always on point. The food is just amazing and I could live off of the Garlic Knots . The Cheese RavioliChocolate Overload Cake and the canoloi were amazing.
D
Davina J
5 contributions
Loved
• 1/23/26
• DoorDash order
Brooklyn Boys never disappoints! We used to constantly say it was a shame they didn't deliver and we are so very glad they joined DoorDash. Although I'd rather not have the extra fees but it's worth it for quick convenience from a fresh and constant tasting pizzeria. The portions are always plenty and we are so glad to have them delivered! Also, they are so accommodating!!
H
Heather W
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Loved
• 6/13/26
• DoorDash order
The shrimp scampi sauce could be better if they made it with cream added into the butter and garlic sauce imho, however, it hit the spot as is. I am a garlic lover, and I loved how much chopped garlic was at the bottom of the pasta. The only thing that would've made it a tiny bit better is if the garlic was a little softer cooked --they were still pretty firm, but pretty good overall. For the amount that I paid for it, I would've expected a little bit more in the portion as well but I'll take what I get when a seafood pasta craving hits in this little town. If you like chocolate cake that's not super rich sweet, the cake was good and I was pleasantly surprised that it wasn't dry.
B
Brian M
4 contributions
Loved
• 3/1/26
• DoorDash order
Last night, we got some incredible pizza from our favorite Italian joint in Keystone Heights, Brooklyn Boy's Pizza/ The P.IG.. We decided to go with the 14-inch Deluxe Pizza (minus mushrooms), a 10-inch Bianco and an order of Italian Fries with extra marinara (because it's the BEST). Like usual, everything was cooked perfectly and the wait wasn't long at all. Some of our usual favorites are the Chicken Cordon Bleu Pizza, the Garbage Stromboli, and their pressed Cuban sandwich. You definitely have to check them out if you want the best pizza around, and that's coming from someone who ran Sabo's kitchen for several years.
Deluxe (14")Italian FriesBianco (10")
A
Amanda K
3 contributions
Liked
• 3/2/26
• DoorDash order
ordered Brooklyn Stromboli which was good and of course the Mozzarella Sticks always a favorite.for desert we got the Chocolate Overload it was good but I can't say it was worth over $12. Just a small piece of chocolate cake. name is deceiving for sure.
