"The most essential meal of the day is pizza!" "Having it (pizza) and not needing it (more pizza) is preferable to needing more pizza and not having it." "If at first pizza fails, try pizza, pizza, pi…
Always delicious. The Pyro is bonkers but I love it. Like a whole pizza and salad combined. Definitely enough for 2 people but ate it all myself anyway. I also cannot not order the Potato Salad. Just so good.
K
Kate S
4 contributions
Loved
• 6/21/25
• DoorDash order
This is my absolute favorite pizza place. Good day? Bad day? Doesn't matter, I'm getting Secret Pizza Society. The crust is salty and crispy and divine. The Unruly Child and El Egante are my personal favs - simple, yet different than anything else I can get in town. You really can't go wrong.
N
Nina K
1 contributions
Loved
• 4/30/22
• DoorDash order
Absolutely delicious... I don't know the last time I had pizza THIS GOOD. The crust is amazing, crunchy but not hard with great flavor. The Se7en was creamy and flavorful, the Jaffe had a little spice that made them a great pairing. Can't wait to order again!!
E
Elizabeth M
3 contributions
Loved
• 4/27/23
• DoorDash order
The El 'Egante is my favorite pizza because the ingredients are so fresh and flavorful. And I always ask for roasted mushrooms on my pizza. I have never tried the Cheezy Bread; but a side of Cheezy Bread is the same cost as 3 Virgil's Black Cherry Sodas which are so very refreshing. But Virgil's Sodas are not an option on the Door Dash menu. So I have learned to order the Cheezy Bread and request that The Secret Pizza Society replace the Cheezy Bread with 3 Virgil's Black Cherry Sodas instead so I can get what I really want. The Secret Pizza Spciety originally suggested that I do this to work around Door Dash's inability to offer Virgil's Black Cherry Sodas on their app. It keeps Door Dash happy and I get what I really want! I just hope I will be able to continue to use this "trick"! Thank you, Secret Pizza Society!!
S
Serenity S
3 contributions
Loved
• 9/13/26
• DoorDash review
Honestly had no clue what to expect, a Pesto Caesar salad gyro sounded like a strange combo. But the portion is huge, a personal sized pizza wrapped around a nice amount of salad! Perfectly balanced :)
