58 Main BBQ & Brew
58 Main BBQ & Brew
58 Main BBQ & Brew

58 Main BBQ & Brew

4.4(1k+)
DashPass
Southern American-American
Store Info
DashPass
4.4(1k+)
$$Southern American-American
"The owners of 58 Main Restaurant & Party House in Brockport are twin brothers, Jon and Marc Marcello.Jon and Marc started buying tables at Brockport's Village Pantry when they were just 14 years old.…
Full Menu
11:00 am - 8:40 pm

Featured Items

$0 delivery fee, first order
pricing & fees
to see delivery time

Featured Items

The "Q for 2"
$64.00
81% (11)
Full Rack (Combo -13 to 15 Ribs)
$50.00
"Fowl" Pig
$36.00
Ribeye (14 Oz. )
$36.00
81% (11)
NY Strip Steak (14 Oz.)
$34.00
75% (8)
BBQ Beef Brisket Dinner
$29.00
88% (27)
Reviews1k+ ratings • 50+ public reviews
4.4
of 5 stars
M
Michelle V
5 contributions
Loved
12/7/23
• DoorDash order
Q for 2 brings so much food! Everything was delicious, hot and was ready when I picked up. No waiting around. The Cornbread is probably the best one my family has ever tasted! The ribs were tender and literally falling off the bone. Their pulled pork is amazing!! The beef briskets were also tender and juicy. This place never disappoints! Best BBQ joint! If you haven't tried it, you're missing out!!
M
Mary L
5 contributions
Liked
3/24/26
• DoorDash order
The Pittsburgh Chicken Salad with steak is by far my favorite. They don't skimp on any toppings and the steak was cooked perfectly to my preferences which is hard considering it's for DoorDash. Would recommend 10/10 and will get again.
M
Mike O
Emerging Expert • 5 contributions
Didn't like
10/27/25
• DoorDash order
The amount of food was great, and it has good flavor. However the ribs took very serious effort to even get the bone off the meat. So the fall off the bone aspect wasn't there like I hoped for. Brisket was good, and portion was great. Half chicken was awesome, and very big, and pulled pork was awesome as well. If I didn't get ribs I probably would have left a 5 star review. Not sure I will ever order ribs again from here, which saddens me. Maybe one day they can change my mind on that. Food was fresh, cornbread was excellent. Saw reviews on the Mac and cheese and it isn't just pasta with shredded cheese melted on top. People saying that have never made Mac and cheese before. The cheese ontop is just a little extra cheese for the finish the pasta is in nice cheese sauce.
C
Cate S
1 contributions
Didn't like
12/16/22
• DoorDash order
Got the wrong sauce with my chicken fingers The potato skins had barely any cheese and didn't come with any sour cream they were very bland. The pulled pork dinner was alright but seemed a bit of a small portion for the price.
H
Heather M
10 contributions
Didn't like
12/27/24
• DoorDash order
The plate is fine, but definitely not worth $21. The little bit of meat sauce is dry and has a weirdly strong cinnamon taste. There was no option to add things like ketchup and mustard. The Mac and cheese that I paid extra to be added tastes bland. The burgers themselves are good, and the fries are crispy. It is good enough to eat, but I will not be ordering the 58 main plate again.
See All

Most Ordered

The most commonly ordered items and dishes from this store

Beverages/Drinks

Perfect Appetizers

ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Jumbo Specialty Wings

All wings served with (1) bleu cheese and celery. ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

From the Pig Pen

All BBQ selections are served with corn bread, baked apples and choice of (2) sides. Our original mild BBQ sauce will be basted on all meats unless specified. Please, CALL before picking a SEASONAL SIDE as your side option. ALL items are served as the description states. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

St. Louis Style Pork Ribs

All BBQ combo dinners are served with corn bread, baked apples and choice of (2) sides. Dry rubbed, slow smoked and glazed with our original mild BBQ sauce. Please, CALL before placing a SEASONAL SIDE as your side option. ALL items are served as the description states. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$.

Burgers

Served on a fresh bricohe roll. All selections include a pickle and choice of (1) side. All burgers are fresh 1/2 pound certified Angus Beef Brand. Please, CALL before picking a SEASONAL SIDE as your side option. ALL items are served as the description states. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Sandwiches

All selections include a pickle and a choice of (1) side. Please CALL to see if Seasonal Sides are available before picking a Seasonal Side as a choice. ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Specialty Wraps

All selections include a pickle and a choice of (1) side. Please CALL to see if Seasonal Sides are available before picking a Seasonal Side as a choice. ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Savory Soups

ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Salads

All salads served over a bed of crisp lettuce and mixed greens. ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Chef Favorites

ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

The Perfect Steak

All selections include a pickle and a choice of (1) side. Please CALL to see if Seasonal Sides are available before picking a Seasonal Side as a choice. ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Fresh Seafood -FRIDAY & SATURDAY ONLY!!!

All seafood is available FRIDAY & SATURDAY ONLY!! Includes Coleslaw and your choice of (1) side. Please CALL before placing a Seasonal Side as your side option. ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Kids Menu

All selections include free soda, milk (no refills), or juice (no refills) and french fries. Children age 12 and under only. ALL items are served as the description states. If you would like to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc. You must $add$ to the item. Typing to ADD additional toppings, sauces, cheese etc., will NOT add to your item. You may remove an item by typing it, but if you wish to ADD additional items you must $add$. Thank You.

Sides

Add your favorite Side Dish to your Order

Add Ons

extra's and sauces

Prices on this menu are set directly by the Merchant.

Prices may differ between Delivery and Pickup.

Checking if the site connection is secured...