The Original Goodie Shop (Tremont Goodie Shop) is a full-line, family-owned bakery nestled in Upper Arlington, Ohio. For 70 years, we 've hand-made our products from scratch and served our customers –…
The goodie shop is one of our favorite bakeries. Everything is great. Our favorite is their Signature Cinnamon Sticks (1 Dz) and Apple Cinnamon Bread delicious on its own and amazing as cream cheese stuffed French toast. Our kids love the Smiley Face Cookies (1/2 Dz)!
K
Kathryn B
3 contributions
Loved
• 5/23/26
• DoorDash order
Truly the best chocolate frosted glazed donut in Columbus -- and I can't think of any better anywhere I've traveled. We've tried every item on the menu over the years and love them all but the glazed donuts and apple fritters are exceptional. And when we go to the shop ourselves, the people working there are friendly, helpful and kind. Such a gem of a bakery!
A
Ayanna J
Emerging Expert • 4 contributions
Loved
• 4/2/26
• DoorDash order
The cinnamon Signature Cinnamon Sticks (1 Dz) were amazing! I can see why they are so popular. The top was crispy and the inside was soft and gooey. The Portion was amazing for the price. The Chocolate Iced Brownie was good as well. The icing was rich and the brownie was a pretty big size. Will definitely be my go-to bakery!
D
Debra M
1 contributions
Loved
• 3/9/26
• DoorDash order
I can't remember the last time I had a cherry danish made, on site, from scratch vs. the mediocre (at best) frozen fare sent to grocery store bakeries to thaw and shelf. These cherry danish were fresh and delicious and harkened fond memories of old school bakery heavenly goodies. Thank you Original Goodie Shop!
A
Al C
Emerging Expert • 183 contributions
Loved
• 2 days ago
• DoorDash order
Whenever possible The Goodie Shop handles requests. If I had to make a suggestion, cut back on the frosting. It tends to overwhelm the Donuts.
The cost is in-line with places like Dunkin and Tim Hortons.
