Jasmine Milk Tea ice cream: what it says on the tin. Tastes like the tea, 10/10. New favorite ice cream ever.
The Ube ice cream is something else, man. The description said "nutty," and, yes, it tastes a bit like almond or pecan, but it isn't too sweet. With the chocolate chunks, it's got balance. Basically, that's some damn good ice cream.
M
M E
7 contributions
Loved
• 6/2/26
• DoorDash order
Omg, so good, gave my arm for it, but so worth it. We usually go to BK, but I wanted something different. Milk Cereal & Cookie Butter so yummy, Killer Chocolate Brownie, After's killed it. The Dubai not my favorite but I don't like the candy either. Will order again...my kid loved it too.
J
Jaimar D
4 contributions
Liked
• 5/13/26
• DoorDash order
The donut is always good and consistent, but this recent purchase it was fantastic and had a great amount of extra icing that I didn't order but highly appreciate. I have been in an afters mood and if they keep up the quality then I'll keep buying. The donut was fresh and just the perfect size to go with two scoops. However, I will say that they been a bit greedy with that second scoop, it's make like 1.5 scoops and not a full two scoops.
N
Natalie L
Local Expert • 36 contributions
Loved
• 12/12/25
• DoorDash order
In the past I'd left both a glowing review and also one w a pic showing how much room was left to be filled in my quart delivered by DoorDash, but the good review was paired w the image (from the 2nd review). I don't know why this happened but hopefully this review fixes that. This is my summary: Afters ice cream is crazy expensive but also so truly amazing tasting. Milk & Sugar Cookies is addicting. The pieces of sugar cookie dough and sprinkles are delicious. I love it especially w the Afters flakes and the fruity pebbles on top. I could eat the entire quart in one sitting but at $22 each, I stop myself. What rubbed me the wrong way last time I ordered was that the quart was not even close to full. The pictures are from the second to last order I placed. You can see how much more room is in there. This wasn't the first time this happened either. I suppose how much you get depends on who's packing it. I understand it settles as it melts but this is way too much room to be left empty. Whomever filled it did a poor job and put in little effort. For $22, it should be packed in there pretty good. That was disappointing. Taste is subjective but value is not. I do hope management reiterates how important it is to give the customer what they pay for. It's one of the most expensive ice cream shops around and I expect Afters to do better. I wish Afters would sell this seasonal flavor in pre-packed quarts like some of the other flavors available in stores. I guess they know what they have w this flavor. There will always be crazy people like me who pay $22 plus tax and $8 tip to satiate their taste buds. Highly recommend but make sure to let them know if your quart isn't fully packed so maybe they'll do something about it!
N
Natalie L
Local Expert • 36 contributions
Liked
• 12/6/25
• DoorDash order
Is it expensive? Yup. But is it good? Absolutely!! I am addicted to the Milk & Sugar Cookies flavor. Pieces of sugar cookie w colored sprinkles in sweet cream ice cream....YUM. The toppings are tasty too. Afters Flakes are my favorite. I'm from out of town where there is no Afters so I treat myself when one is nearby. I love the bubble packaging to keep the ice cream cold. Do yourself a favor and try it.
