My all-time fav is the Cookie Butter Ice Cream (1 pt) and can't go wrong with Cookie Monster Ice Cream (1 pt) .. Salt o pint is literally the best Cookies & Cream duo to ever do it 😋 🙌🏽
L
Lauren G
Loved
• 11/6/25
• DoorDash order
Jasmine Milk Tea Ice Cream (1 pt) had a very light delicious milk tea flavor. If you love ice cream but don't like it extra sugary sweet or just a tea lover you'll LOVE this! I also had the Cookie Butter Ice Cream (1 pt) flavor and it was amazing! If you like cookie butter you'll LOVE this!
S
Sterling V
Loved
• 1/17/24
• DoorDash order
The ice cream is hella expensive but it is truly some of the best ice cream I've ever had. The best flavors are Afters Milk & Cereal Ice Cream (1 pt) and Afters Cookie Butter Ice Cream (1 pt). The only two that are worth it in my opinion. I would skip the Afters Strawberry Cookie Crunch Ice Cream (8 oz). If youre expecting something like the classic strawberry crunch ice bars from Good Humor, you'll probably be disappointed in that one. They package the ice cream really well which is a plus so it's delivered as cold and as fresh as possible.
T
Tara C
Loved
• 3/6/24
• DoorDash order
oh my goodness ! Totally worth every dollar , this is some of the best ice cream ive ever had !, kudos to the creators of Afters Jasmine Milk Tea Ice Cream (1 pt) and Afters Salty Oreo Ice Cream (8 oz) which was my very first order , i wasted no time tearing up 1pt and 8oz 😂 Effortlessy . i want moreeee
E
Elicia S
Didn't like
• 6 days ago
• DoorDash order
Afters Cookie Butter Ice Cream (1 pt) is incredible!
