The pizza was everything we expected. Loaded with the toppings, Greek and garden salads were fresh and lots of cheese and olines on the Greek.
The only disappointments were the beverages. For the price online, we thought we were getting 1 liter bottles of CokeZero snd Smart Water. Instead we got 20 oz soda and small Smart water. The 2 liter Coke on the site was $4.59 but then I saw the Coke Zero at $3.16 and the Smart Water at $4.02 (no size on either of these) so, mistake, I thought these were 1 liter sizes. Please put the size on all the drinks
S
Sean K
2 contributions
Loved
• 5/30/26
• DoorDash order
Amazing NY style pizza. As someone from NY, it was daunting and devastating to miss the pizza back at home but this place truly is it. Great reasonable pricing, great texture and the nostalgic taste of pizza back at home. Highly recommended and is now my to go pizza place. Thank you Alley Cat for bringing home to New England.
Ashley T
10 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/9/26
• DoorDash order
the pizza was great but the fries honestly gross I pay $5.99 at pizza market for fries
and I get a whole pile full and some there was barely any in the box and they were very undercook and soggy as hell waffle fries are meant to be crispy
Seasoned Waffle Fries 👎
R
Rylee D
1 contributions
Loved
• 7/5/25
• DoorDash review
The pizza was absolutely fantastic. I'm originally from New York and it's the only pizza around that compares. I would order this every day if I could!! The pizzas are huge and the price makes sense. The quality is unmatched in the area and the ingredients are amazing!
A
Amy B
1 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/30/24
• DoorDash order
So Disappointed! The pizza was bomb! As usual. BUT, the chicken Plain Tenders-were dry, and definitely PLAIN. No season what so ever. Not tomentiin there were 4 very small pieces of chicken for $8.99? Ya-NO! We will only be returning for their pizza.
