The Gnocchi Al Pesto was absolutely delicious. Personally I'd like a bit more pesto flavor, but the gnocchi were perfect and overall it's a great dish. Plus I'll definitely have leftovers which is a huge plus!
P
Paige S
2 contributions
Loved
• 8/31/25
• DoorDash order
I ordered them extra crispy and they were amazing. I got honey bbq and all were cooked well. I think I got three flats and nine drums which I thought was a good deal. I think they accidentally gave me blue cheese instead of ranch but I would definitely order this again
Missy S
12 contributions
Didn't like
• 4/16/24
• DoorDash order
SUPER disappointed. I paid $23 for a Fettuccine Alfredo - Shrimp meal. The pasta was all stuck into one lump, the garlic bread was rock hard and burnt, and the salad dressing tasted like chemicals. I am afraid to try the mild traditional 12 Wings. I've never had trouble here before but I believe in getting quality food every time.
C
Chris F
2 contributions
Loved
• 4/29/23
• DoorDash order
The Margherita, 12 Wings, Italian Sub and Tirami SU were all excellent. Think pizza had a tad more cheese than I care for. The wings were best in town. Sub was very good, maybe more seasoning and meat. Tiramisu was 10/10. Shocked this is our first time having Amato's---definitely not the last time!
K
Kelly O
Emerging Expert • 13 contributions
Didn't like
• 6/9/23
• DoorDash order
We've frequented Amato's many times but as of recently have not been great. The pizza is so bland; we added salt, pepper, garlic & Italian seasoning & it still was missing flavor. Whoever was on the fryer tonight needs to not rush the food. Our shrimp in the basket was 1/2 raw. The fries were limp, oily & still frozen in the middle. The shrimp needed another 45 seconds in the fryer. The breading was soft, wet & fell off the shrimp. We put both fries & shrimp in the air fryer here at home, but after spending $50 on delivery w/tip, we shouldn't need to cook our food. We won't be ordering from here for awhile.