Please contact the restaurant at (716) 773-9242 if you have any food allergies.
Family-owned and serving Western New York for 80 years and counting, offering classics like All Natural Roast Beef on W…
Cajun fries are just seasoned curly fries. Delicious, but misleading. Also did not come with cheese as advertised, but the gravy went very well with them.
the All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich was tasty and fresh.
M
Mike D
Local Expert • 85 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/4/25
• DoorDash order
I didn't have a chance to review this order until later on using the app. I wish the review option came up immediatelybecausr in the case a picture is worth a thousand words. If I could have shown to the public the size of the all Sunday that I paid ten dollars for or the portions of meat on my sandwiched. Those over ten dollars each. Surprisingly my small onion ring was reasonable. Everyone in the area has eaten at Sndersons and some of their food id great similar id their ice cream. But I have never in my life seen such a small size cup for s small Sunday it wasn't much bigger than a blue cheese dipper cup. To be fair two of those cups together was the size of my Sunday. I literally had a few spoonfuls of ice cream for ten dollars. All I could do was laugh as I ate it because I thought to myself golly G Mr Anderson is making some bank off his small icream Sundays. The bbw beef wasn't ssuceu like it normally is and the original beef much smaller than I remember with no glare for 13 dollars. I give Anderson two stars one of which is for pure nostalgia becausewhat S let down.
M
Mike D
Local Expert • 85 contributions
Didn't like
• 8/9/26
• DoorDash order
dear America, dear Anderson's ice cream and Home of the roast beef sandwich you make great roast beef sandwiches and great barbecue beef sandwiches. Why is it then that you can't put a decent portion in between the buns we certainly love to charge top dollar, but you can't put a decent portion worthy of getting a belly full on one sandwich yet you have no problem charging $14 for a small roast beef and $11 for a small barbecue beef put enough meat in between the buns to satisfy the customer. I have no problem paying and expensive price for a sandwich but it's hard to justify paying $14 for a regular roast beef sandwich and there's no meat on it enough to satiate my 12-year-old stomach let alone my lovely 45 year-old wife's petite tiny stomach what happened to customer service and customer value in the United States of America it's not just Anderson's people don't mind paying high prices for good food, especially in Western New York, but at least make the food a decent value. Andersons gets a -3. The portion sizes are uncalled for and they do not match the pricing north the value. 
B
Brittany K
Emerging Expert • 7 contributions
Didn't like
• 5/6/26
• DoorDash order
The roast beef had hard parts that hurt my teeth. I've never had a problem with these sandwiches but this one was gross.
J
Jeremy A
2 contributions
Didn't like
• 7/21/25
• DoorDash order
Fries were good, roast beef very dry. Couldnt even finish it. Very disappointing. No where near as good as Adrian's
